• Welcome to the forums of Green & Gold Rugby.
    We have recently made some changes to the amount of discussions boards on the forum.
    Over the coming months we will continue to make more changes to make the forum more user friendly for all to use.
    Thanks, Admin.

CAS Rugby 2025

luke_souter67

luke_souter67

Frank Row (1)
hyaaa said:
Couldn't agree more scrumbledore! be interesting to see how these weekend games play out. I'm backing barker 1sts for a blowout against shore during this exhilarating Friday night.
Click to expand...
This will be an exciting game for the Barker firsts vsing Shore. I'm gonna be excited to watch this Friday as I will be in the stands watching and cheering on!!!!!!!
 
hookerthrow1

hookerthrow1

Frank Row (1)
scrumhalf said:
You raise a good point. I think Knox is so competitive in the younger age groups due to the school’s massive size — approximately 3,146 students across both campuses — which is around triple that of some CAS counterparts. As for Waverley and Barker, I think the attraction of strong 1st XV XV may draw young potential talents into the school through the junior years. More academic schools like Cranbrook and Aloys may not appeal as much to young rugby prospects. If Cranbrook can start posting better results and even win the competition a few times, I think its junior programs will grow in skill, as boys looking to thrive both academically and in rugby will be drawn to the Brook over rivaling, less academic CAS schools.

I also think Cranbrook’s 16s and opens teams are made up of a large number of scholarship players, which gives strength to their 16As and Opens teams — but the younger age groups still rely on much smaller boys to compete. You can’t really give a Year 7 kid a rugby scholarship, because by the time he reaches Year 12, he could be a completely different player and not as good as originally projected.
Click to expand...
Cranbrook's 16As this year do not have any scholarships, it should be a good test to see them up against a strong Newington side
 
B

BITTA_footy

Bob McCowan (2)
Can’t agree more

I’m very excited to see how Shore Barker go tomorrow night at alliance. Both sides will put on a great show, and I’m interested to see who from either side steps up for the occasion. I’m sure the Tahs coaches will be watching for some young talent. Any predictions? I think Shore by 3.

Regards,

Bitta
luke_souter67 said:
This will be an exciting game for the Barker firsts vsing Shore. I'm gonna be excited to watch this Friday as I will be in the stands watching and cheering on!!!!!!!
Click to expand...
 
scrumhalf

scrumhalf

Peter Burge (5)
saladsdontwinscrums1 said:
Just buying imports doesn’t work. Yeah it’s great having these amazing individual footballers, but to be successful you have to be a team and work together. These schools think you can just buy imports and win, it doesn’t work like that.
Click to expand...
Well said, i think developing skill and chemistry from a young age is vital to a strong 1sts side down the line, bringing players in the year of 1sts in yr 11 is good in theory but doesnt seem to be working for them as the unfamiliar enviroment and opponents they are exposed to doesnt work for the team at such a high level of footy.
 
luke_souter67

luke_souter67

Frank Row (1)
BITTA_footy said:
Can’t agree more

I’m very excited to see how Shore Barker go tomorrow night at alliance. Both sides will put on a great show, and I’m interested to see who from either side steps up for the occasion. I’m sure the Tahs coaches will be watching for some young talent. Any predictions? I think Shore by 3.

Regards,

Bitta
Click to expand...
Yeah Bitta,

I think on this occasion Barker will go up by 6, but it will be a great game of footy to watch.

Kind regards,
Luke
 
WLF3

WLF3

Billy Sheehan (19)
BITTA_footy said:
Can’t agree more

I’m very excited to see how Shore Barker go tomorrow night at alliance. Both sides will put on a great show, and I’m interested to see who from either side steps up for the occasion. I’m sure the Tahs coaches will be watching for some young talent. Any predictions? I think Shore by 3.

Regards,

Bitta
Click to expand...
Whilst not being a Barker follower, the only thing IMO that may stop Barker winning by 20+ is the effect of the Sanix comp and a wet game.
 
CAS_Rugby

CAS_Rugby

Allen Oxlade (6)
scrumhalf said:
Well said, i think developing skill and chemistry from a young age is vital to a strong 1sts side down the line, bringing players in the year of 1sts in yr 11 is good in theory but doesnt seem to be working for them as the unfamiliar enviroment and opponents they are exposed to doesnt work for the team at such a high level of footy.
Click to expand...
Barker has had plenty of success dropping kids directly into their 1sts.
 
Homer

Homer

Billy Sheehan (19)
scrumhalf said:
You raise a good point. I think Knox is so competitive in the younger age groups due to the school’s massive size — approximately 3,146 students across both campuses — which is around triple that of some CAS counterparts. As for Waverley and Barker, I think the attraction of strong 1st XV XV may draw young potential talents into the school through the junior years. More academic schools like Cranbrook and Aloys may not appeal as much to young rugby prospects. If Cranbrook can start posting better results and even win the competition a few times, I think its junior programs will grow in skill, as boys looking to thrive both academically and in rugby will be drawn to the Brook over rivaling, less academic CAS schools.

I also think Cranbrook’s 16s and opens teams are made up of a large number of scholarship players, which gives strength to their 16As and Opens teams — but the younger age groups still rely on much smaller boys to compete. You can’t really give a Year 7 kid a rugby scholarship, because by the time he reaches Year 12, he could be a completely different player and not as good as originally projected.
Click to expand...
Knox is an academic school as well, finishing only a couple of spots behind Aloys and well ahead of Cranbrook and the rest of the CAS (18th last year and 11th the year before). The demographics at the school also don't lead to rugby as the primary sport, yes they have huge numbers but not so much in the rugby ranks. Like Newington soccer dominates numbers. Numbers can be misleading as well, Joeys is a tiny population but puts out 14 opens teams and occasionally still wins the soccer. Barker has a tiny population and struggles to get 15-20 teams all up but can win the comp continuously.
 
Homer

Homer

Billy Sheehan (19)
CAS_Rugby said:
Barker will eat them alive.
Click to expand...
With Knox beating Shore last week, Waves falling to Joeys and Knox playing Joeys tomorrow we could have a clearer picture on the CAS favourites.
Shore have been improving but the Barker forwards will be too much for them.
 
scrumbledore

scrumbledore

Bob McCowan (2)
Homer said:
Knox is an academic school as well, finishing only a couple of spots behind Aloys and well ahead of Cranbrook and the rest of the CAS (18th last year and 11th the year before). The demographics at the school also don't lead to rugby as the primary sport, yes they have huge numbers but not so much in the rugby ranks. Like Newington soccer dominates numbers. Numbers can be misleading as well, Joeys is a tiny population but puts out 14 opens teams and occasionally still wins the soccer. Barker has a tiny population and struggles to get 15-20 teams all up but can win the comp continuously.
Click to expand...
I think this is a great take.

Knox has definitely maintained strong HSC rankings in recent years, and its broader co-curricular profile reflects that balance. You're also spot on about the numbers; sheer enrolment doesn't always translate to rugby depth or culture. Joeys and Barker prove that quality and tradition often outweigh quantity.

I think it's the deeply embedded rugby culture—built over decades—that drives consistency and success, not just headcount or facilities.
 
hyaaa

hyaaa

Frank Row (1)
James archer #12 said:
Very excited for the game this evening absolutely pumped. I'm expecting a brilliant game from both barker and shore. I'm backing barker by 10. All in all seems like both schools with have a great turn out.
Cheers gents, see you there.

#Number 12
#battery fully charged
Click to expand...
Certainly so James I think everyones excited to see the outcome for this match. Great moment for everyone to see barkers 1sts XV have a full match without too many consistent subs. Interested to see how Will Hargreaves plays, his performance in SANIX was impressive especially after his injury with his knee performing a stunt.
Going to be a great event!

regards,
hyaaa
 
scrumhalf

scrumhalf

Peter Burge (5)
They’re a big side, as always. I haven’t seen enough of their backs to comment much on style or structure, but from what I saw in their holiday fixture against a kiwi team, their forward pack looks solid - physical and well-drilled
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top