Nevergiveup
Frank Nicholson (4)
@scrumhead99 is Cranbrook now at full strength?
CAS Rugby 2024
- Thread starter rod skellet
- Start date
scrumhead99
Fred Wood (13)
This is definitely the strongest team Cranbrook have had this year, but I wouldn't stay full strength with one or two lingering injuries.
Redtilldead24
Frank Nicholson (4)
It’s a rough back end of the CAS draw for Waves and Knox (especially for waves having Knox away). Having to play their two biggest games back to back is a big ask.
Waverlian2024
Stan Wickham (3)
james richards
Allen Oxlade (6)
Ladder:
Barker (9 pts) +112 PD
Knox (6pts) +49 PD
Waverley (6pts) +24 PD
Cranbrook (3pts) -7 PD
Trinity (0pts) -85 PD
St Aloys (0 pts) -93 PD
** Knox v Aloys yet to be considered on the table ... not sure why. When added Knox should be in 1st thanks to the point difference
when added it should be Knox in 1st with 9 points and a PD of +123 if my knowledge of the score being 74-0 is accurate
Barker (9 pts) +112 PD
Knox (6pts) +49 PD
Waverley (6pts) +24 PD
Cranbrook (3pts) -7 PD
Trinity (0pts) -85 PD
St Aloys (0 pts) -93 PD
** Knox v Aloys yet to be considered on the table ... not sure why. When added Knox should be in 1st thanks to the point difference
when added it should be Knox in 1st with 9 points and a PD of +123 if my knowledge of the score being 74-0 is accurate
Last edited:
james richards
Allen Oxlade (6)
Adding to this I think this year will come down to a Barker v Knox final-round game for the shield unless Waverley can pull off a win on their home ground ... thoughts?
The game will be a big one no matter what.
Will either be the two undefeated teams playing each other (if Knox beat Waverley), or Knox trying to force a 3-way premiership.
(Assuming no upsets in Barker and Waverly's other games)
The schedule the last few years has put these games in Term 3, albeit it's not great for the CAS selectors.
Will either be the two undefeated teams playing each other (if Knox beat Waverley), or Knox trying to force a 3-way premiership.
(Assuming no upsets in Barker and Waverly's other games)
The schedule the last few years has put these games in Term 3, albeit it's not great for the CAS selectors.
rugby-OG
Stan Wickham (3)
i have been a bit behind on my CAS knowledge this year and would like to know, who are the most in form players so far this year?
Nevergiveup
Frank Nicholson (4)
Waverley V Knox is at Knox
Hercules Von Grimmelshaus
Allen Oxlade (6)
Was a hell of a game it felt like Barker had it in the pack and Waves had the firepower in the backs. Every time that it seemed Barker had it won they invited Waves back in with penalties. Both No 8’s had immense games and would have been my MoM on both sides. Death Valley is a tough place to get a result and good to see all games in the opens being tight affairs and going down to the wire. 2 wins eachWow Rod, another belter at Death Valley.
Yet another epitome of how school boy rugby is the best of all to watch IMO.
Both sides exhausted each other.
As a Waves supporter it hurt that we dropped the last ball, 5 out, and unmarked, but then again Barker have also had their share over the years of being pipped at the post.
Trust you enjoyed it
james richards
Allen Oxlade (6)
yes i said that but i see how that could be misread I meant "their home ground" as Knox's home ground
rod skellet
Desmond Connor (43)
Why I suggest a 3 way tie is that Waves travel well. Going to Warrawee will not phase the Double Vee, and neither does Knox travelling to Barker. If Waves play their best rugby and keep the ball away from the Knox wingers who have genuine pace, then they can win. And Barker will then need to do the same at home. To beat Knox I think 10 man rugby is the go.
Sigh. Another year, another broken competition.
I don't want this to be construed as Aloys-bashing but... well, there's been a lot of Aloys-bashing this year. Their three results have been 21-39 (commendable), followed by two 70-odd to nil scorelines. In some age groups they field a single team. It's not their fault, but it creates an unbalanced competition and, more importantly, does no good to any of the boys taking part.
Someone needs to fix this.
I don't want this to be construed as Aloys-bashing but... well, there's been a lot of Aloys-bashing this year. Their three results have been 21-39 (commendable), followed by two 70-odd to nil scorelines. In some age groups they field a single team. It's not their fault, but it creates an unbalanced competition and, more importantly, does no good to any of the boys taking part.
Someone needs to fix this.
james richards
Allen Oxlade (6)
What are everyone's thoughts for this weekends round:
Cranbrook v Barker
Knox v Waverley
Aloys v trinity
Personally:
Cranbrook 3+ (barker only just pulling off a win against Waverley I think Cranbrook can pull off an upset on home ground)
Knox 7+
Trinity 20+
Cranbrook v Barker
Knox v Waverley
Aloys v trinity
Personally:
Cranbrook 3+ (barker only just pulling off a win against Waverley I think Cranbrook can pull off an upset on home ground)
Knox 7+
Trinity 20+
The obvious answer is a two tier ISA /CAS comp for rugby only. Problem solved.
JackJill
Ted Fahey (11)
I have been notified there is developments in the consideration of possible an ISA/CAS integration, or possibly Auggies and Oakhill shifting over to match the strengths of programs. Nothing confirmed although.
Soupnasty
Allen Oxlade (6)
If that happens, what does that mean for schools like Pius and Stannies etc
Surely the answer is to leave ISA and CAS and work on improving school rugby programs at Alloys etc