To my mind, the most interesting thing about the CAS selections was how uninteresting they were - by which I mean how few real surprises they contained. Personally, I would have picked Paek (K) ahead of Elwood-Hall (B) on one wing, and I would have picked Goodearl (A) ahead of Watson (K). But I wouldn't call those wrong selections. Picking a team involves not just weighing up the merits of individal players but deciding what kind of game you want to play and how the team wil lfit in together. For instance Whicker (T) offers far more around the park that Kirkby (B), but I can't disagree with Kirkby's selection in the 1sts, because his pass is much better, and that's what's needed to give a good back line the best chance to succeed.
Who's unlucky? Slack-Smith (B) is probably a bit better than reserve for 2nds, as is O'Connor (W). I thought Newby (K) had a chance. Ebeling (T) has had a tough season, shifting position and being on the wrong end of more hospital passes than a player has a right to expect in a single season. Who's lucky? Vevers (A) has been picked out of position and after a lacklustre season, but he has talent and I'd expect him to do a decent job. Incidentally, I understand that Kotobalavu (T) is unavailable, otherwise he would have been in there somewhere, I think.