Inside Shoulder
Nathan Sharpe (72)
An earlier post quoting one of the papers said 29 of 35 were off contract at the end of the season.
since then he has signed Phipps.
Brumbies vs Waratahs Super Rugby-R4 2013
- Thread starter Braveheart81
- Start date
- Status
since then he has signed Phipps.
rugbyskier
Ted Thorn (20)
Most of the regulars in the Gregan/Larkham Stand aren't fans of the Mexican wave either, as it always died when it got around to us. We were too busy watching the game. It seems that the Uni of Canberra students in the south bowl were the instigators.
Loved the Rathboner sign too.
Richo
John Thornett (49)
The students were great fun. Looks like they're trying to emulate "the Zoo" that the Hurricanes (I think) have. If only the Waratahs had some sort of large tertiary education institution nearby that they could target with cheap tickets and t-shirts and stuff.
I will be surprised if Alexander isn't cited.
He might have only stomped on Robinson's leg but it was so blatant and malicious and nowhere near the ball. I think he'll get suspended for it.
It was bizarre. It's so out of character for Alexander and you'd think that even though he's obviously reasonable mates with Robinson (at the very least. I'd be surprised if they're not good friends) and knew it wasn't actually going to do any real damage to Robbo, it was very likely to land him in hot water.
Merrow
Arch Winning (36)
Apparently he hasn't been cited according to a Foxsports article, and is on his way to SA.
Richo
John Thornett (49)
Truly bizarre. Everything to do with the judiciary is an absolute lottery.
Rob42
Nicholas Shehadie (39)
You'd have to assume they considered the yellow card to be punishment enough. Regardless, that should be made public.
Richo
John Thornett (49)
Apparently. Will be interesting to see what happens next time someone gets done for stamping.
gel
Ken Catchpole (46)
The stamping incident is just bizarre.
For a guy who never barges in to (legally or illegally) clear out a ruck and chooses instead to repeatedly appeal to the referee with an outstretched hand it certainly is an odd move to do something that would injure another person that was lying prone and defenseless.
What the hell was he thinking?
For a guy who never barges in to (legally or illegally) clear out a ruck and chooses instead to repeatedly appeal to the referee with an outstretched hand it certainly is an odd move to do something that would injure another person that was lying prone and defenseless.
What the hell was he thinking?
RoffsChoice
Jim Lenehan (48)
Third penalty in as many minutes, he had just bombed a try and now they were preventing one, sometimes a guy just snaps.
Brumby Jack
Steve Williams (59)
Just watched the replay again.
The score of 35-6 looks like a beating but for the Waratahs, Dave Dennis will learn a lot from that much in terms of decision making. At least twice in the 2nd half and with plenty of time to go with the score at 21-6 they declined easy shots at penalty. One of the lineouts ended up being knocked on and the other one went nowhere.
If it then becomes 21-12 then it looks closer and they still could have got something out of the game instead of 4 tries to 0 considering Dennis said that the 3 early penalties the Brumbies kicked put them on the back foot after less than 10 minutes.
The score of 35-6 looks like a beating but for the Waratahs, Dave Dennis will learn a lot from that much in terms of decision making. At least twice in the 2nd half and with plenty of time to go with the score at 21-6 they declined easy shots at penalty. One of the lineouts ended up being knocked on and the other one went nowhere.
If it then becomes 21-12 then it looks closer and they still could have got something out of the game instead of 4 tries to 0 considering Dennis said that the 3 early penalties the Brumbies kicked put them on the back foot after less than 10 minutes.
Rob42
Nicholas Shehadie (39)
Agreed, velour-covered pony mascot. It felt like the Tahs were desperately chasing the game even before the last quarter, when they were only 9 points down. No doubt, though, it felt to them like they were being suffocated by the opposition, which doesn't lend itself to sensible decision-making.
Rob42
Nicholas Shehadie (39)
Sorry, they were more than 9 points down at the time, but still, it felt desperate way too early. Much as crowds love teams eschewing the chance to go for the posts, it's remarkable how often it seems to break the rhythm of a team - perhaps the extra pressure of feeling that you must earn back that 3 points that you've gambled.
I like to watch
David Codey (61)
It's hard to understand how a team with as much experience as the Tahs have,play with such a lack of composure.
rugbyskier
Ted Thorn (20)
So that's what that was about. The PA system wasn't working in the G/L Stand so we didn't hear what was going on.
RoffsChoice
Jim Lenehan (48)
The whole team of champions v champion team story.
Rob42
Nicholas Shehadie (39)
Exactly. That pushover try from the Brumbies was a great example. The Tahs didn't compete for the line-out, so logically they'd be setting their defence (comprised of mostly test-capped players) to stop the maul. And yet they get bumped out of the way in barely a moment. As Kearns pointed out in the commentary, all standing upright and unable to resist the drive.
Credit to the Brumbies forward pack there, it was beautifully executed. But shabby defence from the very experienced Tahs forwards.
I didn't get that.
Surely if your maul defence is so poor, you have to compete at the lineout and try and disrupt their ball otherwise you're going to concede a try.
Can someone help me on the laws here. If there is a 5m lineout, are you only allowed one player behind the lineout on the goal line (i.e. the halfback)? Or could you defend with a two man lineout with the rest of the forwards standing on the goal line ready to hit the maul as soon as it forms?
You could do that, but the waiting forwards could not advance until the maul moved off the line of touch. So you would just be giving it extra time to form and get a bit of momentum before you hit it.
- Status