Pfitzy
Nathan Sharpe (72)
Top end pace is one thing - but it isn't everything.
Brumbies v Waratahs, Sat 1st April, GIO
- Thread starter KOB1987
- Start date
Top end pace is one thing - but it isn't everything.
Berrys insistence to card the Tahs yet let the Brums do whatever they want highlights everything wrong with Super Rugby. The utter lack of consistency is mind boggling. Perese’s high tackle was nothing like Frosts who connected with Jorgensens head with his shoulder but Berry didn’t even bother to look at it.
i was at the game and as soon as that incident popped up on the replay the screen suddenly had some ad to meet the Brumbies Chairman. Added to this the boos and whistles from the crowd when Tahs were attempting conversions and p goals is peak Canberra.
Really would have been nice to leave the stadium with a win but maybe another year asking what went wrong is what the sky blue need
i was at the game and as soon as that incident popped up on the replay the screen suddenly had some ad to meet the Brumbies Chairman. Added to this the boos and whistles from the crowd when Tahs were attempting conversions and p goals is peak Canberra.
Really would have been nice to leave the stadium with a win but maybe another year asking what went wrong is what the sky blue need
The Red Baron
Chilla Wilson (44)
Lightblue
Arch Winning (36)
Yes…loves him. No obsession of personal slander when he did some things wrong, in a team that didn’t win a game for over 12 months! Derpus has no credibility.
molman
Jim Lenehan (48)
I'm looking forward to rewatching the replay of the game having been at the stadium to see how it compares to my live observations. The Tah's had some real tenacity about them and to be honest (yes I'm a Tah's fan so take it for what it is), I feel they should have won that one. I actually thought there was lots of elements of the Brumbies game that was rather ho-hum tonight, but like the best teams they still grind out a win even when they're not at their best. The Brumbies bank of set plays, however, is excellent. You could see them lining up for a number of those tries, including the barnstorming Slipper, which they use to often line up AAA's for. I still feel they're suspectable to a more unstructured game where the errors really creep in for them, including their defence. You could see them struggling when they either lost shape or lost the front foot which I felt the Tah's did a reasonable job at causing at various points.
Also, for the record, I thought Berry had an 'ok' game. Maybe I'll change my mind when I watch it on replay, but by and large I think he got the big things right.
The Tah's lost that game due to numerous little moments, especially when they piled on more pressure due to poor execution (mainly kicking and scrummaging), which was hard to watch at times as it often came off the back of some extended periods of solid defence and real effort. Add in some of the penalties and discipline issues and they allowed the Brumbies to pin them down their end. I'm not sure Larkham will be thrilled with the Brumbies conversion rates in that game as they had more possession and a lot of that down in the 22.. Tah's half of the field.
I feel like if this had been the Tah's we saw in the first game against the Brumbies you'd be pretty happy. Add in a few people like Gleeson, Bell and Gamble and I suspect they would have got that one home.
Also, for the record, I thought Berry had an 'ok' game. Maybe I'll change my mind when I watch it on replay, but by and large I think he got the big things right.
The Tah's lost that game due to numerous little moments, especially when they piled on more pressure due to poor execution (mainly kicking and scrummaging), which was hard to watch at times as it often came off the back of some extended periods of solid defence and real effort. Add in some of the penalties and discipline issues and they allowed the Brumbies to pin them down their end. I'm not sure Larkham will be thrilled with the Brumbies conversion rates in that game as they had more possession and a lot of that down in the 22.. Tah's half of the field.
I feel like if this had been the Tah's we saw in the first game against the Brumbies you'd be pretty happy. Add in a few people like Gleeson, Bell and Gamble and I suspect they would have got that one home.
Last edited:
whitefalcon
Ron Walden (29)
I'm a brumbies fan who was also at the game and I agree. The Tahs looked the better team for most of that match.
whitefalcon
Ron Walden (29)
When the two yellow's were handed out in the first half to the Tahs tightheads, if the Brumbies went to a scrum and the Tahs couldn't bring on a replacement wouldn't that mean they would then go to 12 men?
Jimmy_Crouch
Peter Johnson (47)
Yes, usually but they brought on a loose head (Lambert) and Faulkner switched sides. So in fact they dragged Jorgensen to bring Lambert on
whitefalcon
Ron Walden (29)
AH that makes sense.
I still don't know why 7As (Allan Ala'alatoa) didn't go the scrum again when we were so dominant
A mutterer
Chilla Wilson (44)
was a great game. the word composure was used a lot by the brumbies post match and they definitely had it.
perhaps their instinct that the tahs would invariably find a way to shit the bed as usual led them to believe all they needed was to watch the tahs fuck it up.
waas enjoyable to watch, even if it didnt go the way of the tahs.
perhaps their instinct that the tahs would invariably find a way to shit the bed as usual led them to believe all they needed was to watch the tahs fuck it up.
waas enjoyable to watch, even if it didnt go the way of the tahs.
Slim 293
Stirling Mortlock (74)
The Tahs were always going to put in a spirited performance, but I was just disappointed in the way the Brumbies handled having a two man advantage in the first half... that's when a good team is going to take advantage and they just seemed complacent in those moments.
dusk
Vay Wilson (31)
Give them a break, they have to live in Canberra ffs
Slim 293
Stirling Mortlock (74)
Oh burn... let them stew on that on their short commute home.
John S
Peter Fenwicke (45)
Announcement at the ground said 10,575
John S
Peter Fenwicke (45)
So many times he kicked it straight back down their throats with no chasers extremely frustrating
Well you may laugh, but after attending the match I can only agree with that statement. (From a former referee.)Sorry, I'm only just going back through the comments to see that... Nic Berry... won the match for... the Brumbies?
Just back home in the Blue Mountains, does anyone have a penalty count?
John S
Peter Fenwicke (45)
I just got homeYou know what
John S
Peter Fenwicke (45)
Nope, I may need to watch it on Stan tomorrow/today (just got back home to Nowra)