• Welcome to the forums of Green & Gold Rugby.
    We have recently made some changes to the amount of discussions boards on the forum.
    Over the coming months we will continue to make more changes to make the forum more user friendly for all to use.
    Thanks, Admin.

Brumbies v Rebels Friday 2 June 7.35pm

Dctarget

Tim Horan (67)
If they win, and the Blues lose, they finish 3rd they play the Tahs...

If they win, and and the Blues win, they finish 4th and play the Canes in Canberra...

If they lose, and the Canes win, they finish 5th and play the Canes in Wellington.
So, do we want two Aus teams in two separate qfs or one guaranteed aus team in the semi? Probably the latter.
 

Slim 293

Stirling Mortlock (74)
So if they lose, they are significantly disadvantaged for the quarters. Okay thanks

Actually, my post wasn't entirely accurate...

If the Brumbies lose, and the Canes lose, the Brumbies remain in 4th place...

If the Brumbies lose with a bonus point, and the Canes win without a bonus point, the Brumbies will still remain in 4th place.

If the Brumbies and the Canes finish on the same competition points and games won, the Canes would certainly finish ahead with a a much larger points differential.
 

dusk

Vay Wilson (31)
Actually, my post wasn't entirely accurate...

If the Brumbies lose, and the Canes lose, the Brumbies remain in 4th place...

If the Brumbies lose with a bonus point, and the Canes win without a bonus point, the Brumbies will still remain in 4th place.

If the Brumbies and the Canes finish on the same competition points and games won, the Canes would certainly finish ahead with a a much larger points differential.
Very interesting, do you know if there are any teams where the favourites might try and purposefully lose to get an easiser quarter? Or will a win always guarantee an easier quarter?
 

Wilson

Phil Kearns (64)
Very interesting, do you know if there are any teams where the favourites might try and purposefully lose to get an easiser quarter? Or will a win always guarantee an easier quarter?
Winning is the better option across the board, any team that can shift there placing risks losing hosting rights or a finals place altogether by losing.

The exception is the Chiefs and tahs, who can't change their placings at this stage so would put less importance on winning. I guess you could argue the Chiefs could lose to try and guarantee they'd host the Force in the quarters, but that would be insane behaviour. That said, the likely alternative is the Reds and they're the only team to beat the Chiefs this year, so you never know...
 

dusk

Vay Wilson (31)
Winning is the better option across the board, any team that can shift there placing risks losing hosting rights or a finals place altogether by losing.

The exception is the Chiefs and tahs, who can't change their placings at this stage so would put less importance on winning. I guess you could argue the Chiefs could lose to try and guarantee they'd host the Force in the quarters, but that would be insane behaviour. That said, the likely alternative is the Reds and they're the only team to beat the Chiefs this year, so you never know...
Makes sense. I have no doubts that the Tahs will be putting their all in against Moana, especially for Hoops last home game.
 

zer0

John Thornett (49)
On the other side of the equation, a mere 89 point differential for the Brumbies to overcome to earn a home quarterfinal.

Get amongst it.
 
Last edited:
Top