My side for Saturday, with explanations
Sio - I've read all the amateur diagnosis here, but I believe Slipper needs a rest, and wouldn't play him again before the WC. Besides, Sio's been in great form off the bench, let's see how he goes starting
Moore - Goes without saying, although he's been below his best in the two tests so far and needs to lift
Kepu - Holmes is fine, but still our best TH imo.
Skelton - Offers something different that we need to build on. He still has a way to go, but won't do it watching on TV
Horwill - Better option to start then Mumm, who is more a lock/6 option. Could still cement a permanent spot, I don't think Simmons is ireplaceable
Fardy - A lock-in
Pocock - My toughest decision. We will miss the driving defence of Hooper at the start, which can kill an attacking raid, but our performance at the breakdown against the Boks has convinced me this is the way to go
Palu - We need his power in attack and defence, and neither McCalman nor Higgers locked in a spot. Go hard, and come off after 50
Phipps - Lock-in
Foley - This is still open, but imo has got a points decision over Cooper at this stage
To'omua - A lock-in, but if not fit Giteau
Kuridrani - Lock-in
AAC (Adam Ashley-Cooper) - Would have had him on the bench before the tests, but has proved why we keep picking him. Not spectacular, but never has a bad one
Tomane - Still a question mark in D, but has earned the right for this one.
Izzy - Lock-in
Bench
TPN, actually scrummaging better than Moore, but can't throw and isn't captain
Smith - See above, Slipper rests
Holmes - Has proved to be the answer as back-up TH (there is no other)
Mumm - Good versatile replacement for lock or 6
Hooper - At 50 Palu comes off, Pocock to 8 and Hooper to 7
White - Best option
Giteau - Covers 10 & 12. His experience could be a real bonus late in a tight one
Beale - A gamble, but gets it over Mitchell could he could win a tight one if we're behind, a chip and regather, a deft little pass to a man in space, a 55 metre penalty kick, whatever. If we're in front, I don't put him on!