C
Casnovian
Guest
Pleash
Wilson
Nadruku
For 1 2 and 3 from a snout
Wilson
Nadruku
For 1 2 and 3 from a snout
Pleash
Wilson
Nadruku
For 1 2 and 3 from a snout
Nadruku never took my eye in the tournament (at THP though he was listed in the programme as LHP) and I watched him for quite a while because I knew who he was related to - but that was obviously more my observing than his playing.
He started in just 2 of the 4 games and interestingly was on the bench in the play-off game. The ACT scrum bothered the NSW I scrum though: they beat them to the hit a lot; so he must have been influential in the process.
I have no qualms about the other two front rowers, but am still non-plussed about hooker Manu missing out on both teams. I can only conclude that one bad throwing to the line out day in windy conditions counted against him.
.
I have it from a good source that tomorrows team (atleast the backline) is as follows:
9. Pulver
10. McIntyre
11. Kellaway
12. Stewart
13. Foketi
14. Robinson
15. Placid
Front row selections are often perplexing. I've always been lead to believe that props are chosen on the following KPI's in order of performance:
1. Scrum
2. Lineout lifting
3. Defence/Tackle
4.Cleanout/breakdown
5. Carrying the ball
As you've seen more performances than anyone over the last 3 weeks LG I'd be interested in your thoughts selection wise if these KPI's had been applied?
Well said.
Playing Colts with and against boys a couple of years older will be their first hurdle especially those who play in the tight five. They would have done some gym work at school but some of the Colts would have been putting in heaps more than they have ever done and that is on top of what the older Colts did at school themselves.
There will be a Darwinian weeding out of players even before they get to Grade though some will get to Grade before their time because of the poor depth some clubs have now. That will serve them no good but it is the way of the world in Oz club rugby.
Many of the tight five forwards will find out what they have already expected, that they won't be big enough to play prop or lock or 8 as senior players; so some of them will look at playing hooker or 6 or 7. There will be a host of star Oz schools forwards who will end up as notters - not really locks or 6s or 8s but too small, unless they have a notable point of difference, to play in their school position. They may end up in Grade and that's about it, and maybe not in the Ones.
2nd rowers will find a few giraffes like some Pyles, Nevilles or Douglases blocking their way, yet they were unheard of as schools players. Props may take 5 years to get to the level in senior rugby that they were at school and then they may find players from the school Twos in front of them because they dealt with the senior scrumming laws better and got stronger than they did, despite their best efforts.
Backs will have similar problems though not as many as the forwards. Players with old heads at school will be playing against men a few years later who have the 21 year old head at 21, that they had at 18.
In all positions you will have lads that were physically mature at 17 but notice others catching up with them later. Some, hopefully not too many who end up playing for Oz Schools or the A team, will find out that they are not tough enough to advance much after they leave school.
And yarda, yarda - I digress.
.
ummm....because its a huge achievement in its own right and it's fun to try and see who will make it and why.Very well said Lee. Also this is exactly why I dont understand the high level of posts on these soon to be nobodies. Private school players who forgo colts rugby in Yr 12 will also find it harder to make the transition.
one other thing is that it's an insight into the future of the s15 and wallabies.......as are the 20s which are a better indicator for this.....and more worryingNo doubt it is a great achievement but the level of analysis that some people make is ..... I'll let someone else finish that sentence.
Oz Schools 70 - Tongan Schools 13
• 1. Pleash was very active and had an outstanding burst from the lineout through several tacklers to score. At only 92kgs though he will have to put on a bit of pork down the track to play the position in senior rugby.
• 23. Jones, the 16 year old star of the Oz Schools tournament, had 3-4 runs on the right wing when he came on late and they were all highlight reel stuff. Before the match I didn't know why centre Robinson was starting on the wing instead of Jones and hopefully this will be the last time. This lad is a cracking player and very quick.
You almost got it. I saw a selection worksheet last year (and work book which was guarded like it was gold and returnable on completion of the camp at the National Titles).
I suppose different coaches/managers/administrators have different ideas about their intellectual property.
Positions have specific competencies - for example for prop
1. Set piece ( Scrum Body Shape & Dominance)
2. Set piece (Lineout, Shifting and Lifting)
3. Tackle Contest Support (Accuracy & Past the Ball Focus)
4. Defence (Set Play and Primary Role at Breakdown)
5. Attack (Catch & Pass / Ball Carry)
Core Competencies (expected from all players)
1. Effort on Effort
2. Tackle - Willingness and Effectiveness
3. Discipline
4. Physicality - Willingness
5. Support - Attack and Defence
AND...........
Point of difference - What makes the player stand out!
I'm surprised that Pleash is only 92kg as from what I saw at the National Champs he plays well above that weight. I'm sure the ARU minders will get him onto a good bulking up program as he has enormous potential as a 1 - do you know how old he is LG and whether he's able to back up next year?
I spoke to someone this morning who went to last nights game and who described Jones as invoking a "Campese" air of expectation in the crowd whenever the ball is headed his way with plenty of people rising from their seats in anticipation of him doing something quite brilliant once he has the ball in his hands - and the outcome is that he meets the crowds expectations quite often. Newbie suggested recently that Kellaway might make an early transition into the Australian 7's team - I think that H Jones will be there about the same time if not even earlier.