Schadenfreude
John Solomon (38)
So what's the chances an exception may be made to allow more players from Argentina into Super Rugby?
There are talks and it was promised that by 2016 a Argentinian team will be entered into the competition.So what's the chances an exception may be made to allow more players from Argentina into Super Rugby?
Hi. Thank you so much for your contribution. I am currently in Brazil so French rugby matches do not get shown here so much and one got to rely on opinions of journalist rather than following the games one self. So I thank you for your input and sharing your observations and I hope you will continue with your positive feedback in the futureHi all. As a Pumas fan myself, I thought it could be useful to add the french perspective on a few players, as in the SH few people can see them regularly. I don't get to see the Pampas' games, so I'll only comment on European-based players.
Hookers:
With Mario Ledesma having been such a legend, hookers have not really developped in the last decade. Alberto Vernet Basualdo and Eusebio Guiñazú are decent players, specially come scrumtime, but struggle in open play and at lineout throwing. Agustín Creevy is probably the find of the season. Fabien Galthié (Montpellier's coach, you may remember him from his playing days not too long ago) seems to have a thing for Argentine players, and has been very successful in spotting the good ones rather early. Creevy plays like a fourth backrower, being very good at the breakdown and always making himself available for his fly-half. Good enough at lineout throwing and good at scrums, although this is perhaps the only point in which the "older" ones are better than him. He's a sure starter.
I've heard that the Pampas' hooker is good, but haven't seen him.
Props:
Let me put it this way: I seriously think that if the seventh-choice Argentina prop had an Aussi granny, he would be Wallaby material. The depth here is trully impressive. In their last Top 14 game, Montpellier had an all-Puma starting frontrow (Juan Figallo and Maximiliano Bustos being the props), you can see Stade Français having two argentine props simultaneously (Rodrigo Roncero and Nahuel Tetaz Chaparro), and you can add a starter for Biarritz, Leicester Tigers and Racing Métro (Francisco Gómez Kodela, Marcos Ayerza and Juan Pablo Orlandi respectively). They just love scrums, and for some of them (notably Ayerza and Figallo amongst the younger ones), are very mobile too. Off these, Orlandi is likely to miss out (he's a solid scrummager, but not much else), as may Gómez Kodela in favour of someone I don't know.
Locks:
No one, of any nationality, can talk of the best locks in France without mentioning Patricio Albacete. The guy is just awesome. After him, there seems to be a big gap, though. Biarritz's Manuel Carizza is alright, but light years away from Albacete.
Backrowers:
As an introduction, it should be said that the Argies prefer their backrowers in the french style. They don't generally use openside or blindside, so the backrowers tend to be somewhere in between the specialized kind that you see in english-speaking countries or in South Africa (like Heinrich Brüssow or Jerry Collins, for instance).
I think this is an area of concern for Argentina. They have two highly regarded backrowers: Juan Martín Fernández Lobbe is, on form, one of the best ones in Europe. But he's been injured for a long time and he's not yet back to his best. Being his age (31), you can never be certain that he'll be back to form. Juan Manuel Leguizamón, who you may remember from youtube wonders such as this, this and this one, is also highly regarded, but hasn't had the best of seasons with soon-to-be-relegated Lyon. Besides that, the world cup ones as Farías and Senatore may get gametime, despite being no longer very young. Racing Métro's Galindo does well for his club, but has never been considered by the Pumas coaches for a real stint (he's not young either though)
Halfbacks:
Nicolás Vergallo is third (or even fourth) choice for Toulouse, which doesn't necessarilly mean he's bad, but he hasn't really had gametime this year. Agustín Figuerola is second choice at 11th-placed Brive, while Alfredo Lalanne is playing for London Scottish in the RFU Championship. They really haven't ben able to replace Agustín Pichot, so let's hope they have a few good ones playing for Pampas.
Inside backs+fullback:
I won't talk about Felipe Contepomi, as I assume you all know him. He's playing a lot and very well for Paris, though, after two seasons being Jonny Wilkinson's replacement at Toulon. At Stade Français his inside center has been most often Martín Rodríguez Gurruchaga. He's been playing very well, both defense and attack. Montpellier's Santiago Fernández has also been having a good season, playing outside, or insted of, François Trinh-Duc. Then Biarritz's Marcelo Bosch has been playing both 10 and 13. My personal favourite, despite a tendency not to give the ball to his wingers, he always looks for the break (the space, not the face), is a good defender, would add some weight in midfield and is the author of the sexiest penalty kick of the WC. Gonzalo Tiesi has been injured since the WC, so it's impossible to know if he'll be back to his level for the 4N. He'll probably get test gametime in June, so we should be able to see. These guys are all (maybe except Tiesi) playmaking types, who like to take the ball close to the gainline and put their partners into space. Fernández and Rodríguez are also very good at the long-passing game (something I feel Contepomi lacks). Tiesi is more of a straight runner, but also has good ball-in-hand skills.
Wingers:
Plenty to choose from here. Gonzalo Camacho, as was said before, has not scored many tries in his career, but he can finish a try and, most importantly, is a constant threat. Same with Horacio Agulla, who is a very good defender and can do the necessary finishing job when asked. He has been a good complement for Alex Tuilagi at Leicester. Because of his muscly type, good defense and low centre of gravity, we're likely to see some of him playing 13. Juan Imhoff has been one of the most impressive outside backs this season in the Top 14. Lucas González Amorosino has a monster sidestep. He's a bit Israel Dagg-ish - he's the kind of fullback that makes the opposite team change a gameplan and avoid kicking for territory. Imhoff, Camacho and Amorosino have only one thing in mind: going forward (a bit like Ioane). Agulla is more tactical. Finally, Martín Bustos Moyano is a reliable winger; good in defense, able to gain metres and finish off a try. Plus, he's by far the most accurate Argentine goal kicker (he's actually the only Argentine to be a first-choice kicker in a french club).
If I was to choose a top matchday 22, I'd go for (I'm assuming the oldies won't participate, but they may):
1. Figallo
2. Creevy
3. Bustos
4. Carizza
5. Albacete
6. Senatore
7. Leguizamón
8. JMFL
9. Figuerola
10. Fernández
11. Imhoff
12. Rodríguez Gurruchaga
13. Bosch
14. Agulla
15. González Amorosino
16. ???
17. Ayerza
18. Galarza
19. Farías
20. Vergallo
21. Tiesi
22. Camacho
Hi. Thank you so much for your contribution. I am currently in Brazil so French rugby matches do not get shown here so much and one got to rely on opinions of journalist rather than following the games one self. So I thank you for your input and sharing your observations and I hope you will continue with your positive feedback in the future
While we are with the French what is your thought on 19 year old loosehead prop Jefferson Poirot? He destroyed the Scarlets tighthead according to reports and look a very bright prospect for France.
I just have a minor problem with that 15.
1. Figallo
2. Creevy
3. Bustos
4. Carizza
5. Albacete
6. Senatore
7. Leguizamón
8. JMFL
9. Figuerola
10. Fernández/Bosch
11. Imhoff
12. Santiago Fernández
13. Tiesi
14. Agulla
15. González Amorosino/Rodríguez Gurruchaga
I always believe in play a player in his best position. This is where Bosch and Gurruchaga comes in. Bosch is 1 a flyhalf 2 a outside centre. He can play it but nowhere as good as he is a flyhalf. Gurruchaga the same. He is a better fullback than center and he is more comfortable there. Tiesi loves outside center and has been the best performer in that position. So the tough choice would be speedy Gonzales or Pato. Also the Pampas captain Julio Farias Cabello been in very good form and it will be surprising if he does not find he's way into the squad.
Totally agree. The 12 position is going to be the problem position and a lot of head scratching for that one. We have bundles of 10's , wingers and FB's.That's a fair point. I went with the positions they were mostly playing on, but I think Phelan is more likely to play them in their prefered position. I also have doubts about Fernández's defence at 12. I do like Bosch at 10 though.
Re: Poirot, we have a lot of young losseheads coming (look, I'm already talking about France in the first person, he). The U20 scrum is destroying everyone in the 6N, I'm looking forward to see how they do in the JWC. Yann Watremez and Sébastien Taofifenua are very young LHP (22 and 19 years old) that are keeping big shots on the bench (Barcella and Schuster). Poirot looks promising, but needs more gametime. They're all very young, so there's no need to rush them into the french side. The main problem is at tighthead, or in props that can play both sides (as in Europe benches are 8 players, including an entire frontrow).
Brazil are still babies compared to most nations in International rugby but they improved a lot just in a few years. They have beaten us in the sevens once although we came back and won the tournament it is still remarkable. I think the sevens game is really a good piece of advertisement to get the public interested in Rugby as total. Sevens make more teams competitive as we have seen a team like Kenya beating Australia in it recently. Its not the 15 man game and Australians will not pay attention too much to it but in lower tier countries that is like winning the WC in the 15 man game. The people start to take interest in rugby as a whole. Brazil finished third in the CONSUR 2011 Sevens which is the best ever finish for Brazil as rugby continues to experience substantial growth across the world´s fifth largest country. Just because of that and the won over Paraguay the popular TV channels are showing now rugby on it which was unheard of in the past. They are still Tier 3 but for rugby in general it is a big win. Brazilians are born natural athletes not in size normally but with pace and skill. They just need to transfer that skill from foot to hand!CD, given that Brazil will be hosting the first Olympics Rugby sevens ever in four years' time, and them having teams in both mens and womens as hosts, wonder what they are doing to prepare for that?
I am aware the Brazilian womens team have been in few international sevens tournaments but their skill levels are fairly average...but their figures and looks aren't from what I have observed!
lol I have the honour to vist SA numerous times with my dad. My first game I saw was Boland vs WP at Newlands where Boland shocked them by exploiting Louis Koen. Krige was injured and Boland ran whole day at him and won the match. It was a great game. My dad a very big rugby fan he been following the Jaguars to SA in previous years and fell in love with the countries scenery specially Cape Town.sorry CD only discover this thread now. look like we have another WeePee supporter on board. Welkom Boet, I do run the Vodacom Cup thread also here and you are welcome to give me a bit of a hard time like the others.
Would like to know a bit more from yourself and more input on the braai thread will be welcomed.
OK Boland is better!lol I have the honour to vist SA numerous times with my dad. My first game I saw was Boland vs WP at Newlands where Boland shocked them by exploiting Louis Koen. Krige was injured and Boland ran whole day at him and won the match. It was a great game. My dad a very big rugby fan he been following the Jaguars to SA in previous years and fell in love with the countries scenery specially Cape Town.
Another aspect that makes touring Argentina fun is the fact that South Africans hold the revered status of founding fathers in their small rugby community - especially Dr Danie Craven.
Barry Heatlie, the man who holds the distinction of having led South Africa to its first international victory, settled in Buenos Aires in 1905 after he had run into personal troubles and felt the need to leave the country.
In South America Heatlie joined a sugar company, of which he became general manager by the time of his retirement in 1924, and is credited with having played an important role in establishing the game of rugby in Buenos Aires.
South Africa gave further impetus to rugby in the Argentina by sending a Junior Springbok rugby team to tour there in 1932 and 1959 and Gazelles teams in 1966 and 1972.
By inviting the Pumas to make a tour to South Africa in 1965 Dr Craven effectively placed Argentina on the IRB's agenda and it is a gesture that has never been forgotten.
Before the 1965 tour Craven had assigned the Izak van Heerden to prepare the Puma team and to take charge of them on tour and the visionary Natalian is often described as "the father of Argentine rugby."
The Pumas, however, have a sense that it is time for the pupil to teach the master the lesson. In the guise of the South American Jaguars - a ruse dreamt up by Craven to give his beloved Springboks some international exposure during the wilderness years of isolation - they beat the Boks 21-12 in Bloemfontein in 1980, with the great Hugo Porta scoring all their points, but they have never done so in the blue-and-white of Argentina
Craven is such a wonderful person. He's thought are always towards rugby and nothing else. If the world had another few of them rugby would have been global almost competing with football. That game was in 82 btw. 1980 the games was in South America. I saw videos of the 82 Series and the Jaquars got hammered in the first two tests but Porta was the rugby version of Maradonna. That SA side were a great side as well narowly losing that series in NZ with being flour bombed and all. The true reflection of that game it should have been a draw which was a great reflection of that series and how great both those NZ and SA sides were.OK Boland is better!
CD I opened a Danie Craven thread when he turned 100 years. he sure played a huge role in Argentinias rugby.
http://www.greenandgoldrugby.com/co...n-100-years-long-live-the-craven-spirit.6174/
He send Izak van Heerden over to Argentinia to grow rugby
Supersport
This game to start in half an hour at Markooter field Stellenbosch
SA U20 Invitational XV: 15 Dillyn Leyds, 14 Quinton Norris, 13 Johnny Kotze, 12 Kobus van Wyk, 11 Ruwellyn Isbell, 10 Harold Vorster, 9 Hlanhla Hlungwane, 8 Cobus Nel, 7 Leneve Dames, 6 Shaun Adendorf, 5 Marvin Orrie, 4 Jacques du Plessis, 3 Neethling Fouché, 2 Stephan Coetzee, 1 Marzuq Maarman.
Replacements: 16 Jaco Visagie, 17 Andrew Beerwinkel, 18 Henkus van Wyk, 19 Lungelo Chonco, 20 Rayn Smid, 21 Wian van der Walt, 22 TBC, 23 TBC.
Argentina Under-20: 15 Gonzalo Ruiz, 14 Santiago Cordero, 13 Joaquín Paz, 12 Juan Ignacio Brex, 11 Franco Cuaranta, 10 Sebastián Poet (captain), 9 Felipe Ezcurra, 8 Federico Aguiar, 7 Leandro Ramela, 6 Pablo Matera, 5 Rodrigo Parad Heit, 4 Ladislao Uriburu, 3 Mariano Sánchez, 2 Germán Lefort, 1 Matías Sambrán
Replacements: 16 Santiago García Botta, 17 Santiago Iglesias, 18 Tomás Bruno, 19 Gaspar Oberti, 20 Lautaro Casado, 21 Rodolfo Ambrosio, 22 Juan Cappiello, 23 Germán Klubus
Date: Tuesday, April 17
Venue: Markötter Stadium, Stellenbosch
Kick-off: 16.00 (14.00 GMT)
Referee: François Groenewald (South Africa)
Assistant referees: Marius van der Westhuizen (South Africa), Cwengile Jadezweni (South Africa)