2015S15 SA vs NZ matches
- Thread starter PaarlBok
- Start date
- Status
PaarlBok
Rod McCall (65)
This has been coming some time. The Sharks taking their intimidation tactic one step to far this year. Maybe this happen when you get older, every rugby player experiense this. Deysel was simply stupid but dont know to play rugby different. The Saders were superb.
Brumby Jack
Steve Williams (59)
7 weeks/6 matches for Deysel
http://www.sanzarrugby.com/superrugby/news/jean-deysel-banned-for-seven-weeks/
http://www.sanzarrugby.com/superrugby/news/jean-deysel-banned-for-seven-weeks/
waiopehu oldboy
George Smith (75)
^^^^^^^ seems about right & 3 weeks/ 2 matches longer than I thought he'd get. Can't say it's restored my faith in the judiciary process & outcomes but it's a start.
Mortal Wombat
Allen Oxlade (6)
That seems like a just punishment, but I'm sure there are people in South Africa and elsewhere wondering why Horwill only got one week for a very similar blow, albeit one struck with fist rather than knee.
It never ceases to amaze me how rugby can't get this stuff right, or at least consistent.
Strewthcobber
Simon Poidevin (60)
I actually think the process is pretty clear and you can generally predict what the suspension will be once you are familiar with Regulation 17, especially appendix 1.
They almost always discount the penalty because the player is so sorry and its so out of character which is where the judiciary undermine themselves and the way byes are being handled at the moment is ridiculous.
SANZAR always publish the details too which can make for interesting reading.
http://www.sanzarrugby.com/superrugby/news/jean-deysel-banned-for-seven-weeks/
They almost always discount the penalty because the player is so sorry and its so out of character which is where the judiciary undermine themselves and the way byes are being handled at the moment is ridiculous.
SANZAR always publish the details too which can make for interesting reading.
http://www.sanzarrugby.com/superrugby/news/jean-deysel-banned-for-seven-weeks/
waiopehu oldboy
George Smith (75)
^^^^^^^^^^ problem being that you then get a Steyn-like decision that just makes it all look a bit random & it then takes while for one's faith to almost be restored, then you get a Steyn-like decision etc etc........
Gnostic
Mark Ella (57)
Like any process where the judiciary is allowed discretion to maximum sentence as provided by law will almost never be used.
I much prefer a mandatory penalty system with increasing penalty range for repeat offenders. ie:- Levl 1 Level 2 etc etc.
The current system just leads to the derision of the whole process and that outcome is not desirable for anybody.
Blue
Andrew Slack (58)
Louw yes.
Kruger fell out of favor last year for reasons unknown and id highly unlikely to return to Bok duty unless there are many injuries. Bulls do miss him though.
Flip has not gone anywhere. Had surgery off season. Back on the bench for the Bulls this weekend which is huge. The current no4 is the weakest link in the Bulls pack and needs to be replaced. That upright running long-haired blonde fella. Percy on roids.
I think too much is being made of players leaving and too little about poor coaching and the management of young talent. I think this is where SA have fallen behind the 8 ball in a big way.
When clearly the best coach in Super Rugby coaches the Lions you know your rugby is in the shit. Ludeke, Gold, Coetzee. If anyone thinks these guys are world class coaches please try tell me with a straight face. I like Gold. But maybe he is a good assistant and analyst. He has difficult personalities in the Sharks and they are running riot. Ludeke has been more adventurous until lst weekend when he panicked and had the Bulls play old school against the Lions and that played into their hands. The bet thing to happen to Stormers Rugby in 10 years is that Coetzee will be leaving. He has held them back.
SA has oodles of young talent. But the bulk of them seem to disappear year after year or they just do not fulfil promise. Some just probably have it coached out of them.
That's what SA needs to fix to cope with player drain. Not some looney idea of keeping players in SA that will never work, like SARU has come up with recently.
PaarlBok
Rod McCall (65)
PS du Toit & Etsebeth.
PaarlBok
Rod McCall (65)
Yep Oupa Matfield will be there. It will be interesting to see if Meyer will reward the Stormers fatties specially Koch. He dominate them all this season.
Dismal Pillock
Michael Lynagh (62)
WGTN piss about and make hawd work of it vs the Shawks. Fairly belaboured effort to eke out the win.
Nonu with plenty of fuckups, turnovers, spillage etc.
Big effort from Ardie Savea.
Damn, a 2016 AB back row of A.Savea, A.Ioane & K.Read...... it'd be like have 10 1/2 backs
Nonu with plenty of fuckups, turnovers, spillage etc.
Big effort from Ardie Savea.
Damn, a 2016 AB back row of A.Savea, A.Ioane & K.Read...... it'd be like have 10 1/2 backs
ACR
Desmond Connor (43)
Jesus, some home town calls in the Lions v Highlanders game. 12 penalties to 3. Lions with the dominant scrum (on their own feed) but not all of those were penalties. I don't even know how mauls work anymore.
Pretty pitiful losing to a team that only has a good scrum. Highlanders shot themselves in the foot playing so flat, they have never had the gift of patience. So much firepower in the back line, they think they need to use it every single play. Fekitoa was throwing passes like a madman. Sopoaga kicking it out on the full when they just needed an ounce of composure was a killer.
The Lions, well, they're basically a typical South African team aren't they. Big kicks, mauls, set pieces, expect they can't throw a line out for shit. Played big and strong and it was good for the win this time. Well done to them.
Pretty pitiful losing to a team that only has a good scrum. Highlanders shot themselves in the foot playing so flat, they have never had the gift of patience. So much firepower in the back line, they think they need to use it every single play. Fekitoa was throwing passes like a madman. Sopoaga kicking it out on the full when they just needed an ounce of composure was a killer.
The Lions, well, they're basically a typical South African team aren't they. Big kicks, mauls, set pieces, expect they can't throw a line out for shit. Played big and strong and it was good for the win this time. Well done to them.
Dan54
David Wilson (68)
Yep ACR, thought the Lions played well to their strengths and deserved win. Agree Fekitoa would look back and wish he used softer hands in a couple of passes, but also thought the Clan ran out of puff a bit at end, maybe high veldt kicking in.
Know what you mean about mauls, I figure these days if you set a maul, refs seem to allow you to do whatever you want, and basically the defensive team can do virtually nothing, was very confused with some of those calls.
Know what you mean about mauls, I figure these days if you set a maul, refs seem to allow you to do whatever you want, and basically the defensive team can do virtually nothing, was very confused with some of those calls.
Dismal Pillock
Michael Lynagh (62)
Joubert ignores all his local boys knock-ons, forward passes, maul joinings from the North Pole, etc, "play on".
When even the south african commentators admit, for the first time since the Boer War, that a visiting team have not got "the rub of the green" from a ref then you know you have just had your awse cheeks torn asunder and the innards scattered all over sunny downtown Jo-Burg in broad daylight.
Didnt help that the Highlanders seemed to run out of puff in the last 10 either.
- Status