Lee Grant
John Eales (66)
General
I agree with your comments on Ma'afu's game on Friday. He and Slipper were both strong in the scrums and rucks, what's more they didn't chip kick it. To me TPN had his best game on Friday. Prior to then, he looked unwell (and out of form).
Dean's continued selection of Alexander at THP has stopped the improvement of the Oz scrum IMO. True, scrummaging is an 8 man activity but Benny's hinging down has been chronic, give or take a game or two when he pushes up. I actually like to see his head pop up every now and then. Though that can be pinged also it's at least a promising sign.
It is a pity that Slipper and Robinson were injured at the start of the 2011 test season as the best Oz THP in Super rugby, Kepu, did not get a shot at the 3 jersey. Mind you Deans would probably have picked Benny anyway.
TPN has been poorly coached. I remember writing after I saw his first starting S14 game that he wouldn't last long in pro rugby with such a risky tackling technique. It has not served him, or the teams he has played for, very well IMO.