Search results

You missed my point, that you are fine with anyone slipping the boot into GC. Not so with this bloke. If you believe that body of work was above criticism, then I would suggest that your personal relationship is blinding you to the facts. It's nice that you are loyal, I suppose.

How is this any different from the absolute caning that Greg Crowden gets about his articles, that go without comment from you? With respect, had you not chided BR on this site at the behest of IP originally, this would never have become an issue. Seriously,deadlines/pressure is no excuse for...

In the 1's,

The side was selected before anyone knew of the freakish conditions they were going to play in.

Makes much more sense Lee.

Too late, we are parramatta!

Interesting that you do not include Cotton who I considered the unluckiest of the Oakhill boys. All this seems reasonable to me, however you are underestimating Phillips. I know nothing about the Stannies kid that was preferred. I agree with you that some of the size that your guys offer is...

judging by a few games I have seen Greg Peterson play for the Marlins, he is rightfully being overlooked by the Tahs. he is not super standard ATM

Seems to me that they are encouraged to stay behind the ball carrier, so they are available for the quick recycle, which is great for the under 11's.

yep, too one dimensional,need more runners to stop the runner being monstered by multiple defenders. wet weather footie = more kicking and lots of switches when passing. I didn't see any of the above the other night.

No.9 Your post might have some merit if you could nominate the Oakhill kids and rationalise while they would be a better selection, rather than just bleat that is unfair that all the other selectors don't see whatever it is that you see. From the trials, the fullback was unlucky. maybe I would...

No 9 Read your posts after the trials, you knew the makeup of the sides then as well.Your point now is what?

snort, so you are saying that Trinity has a heap of great players. It's just most of them are no good in the position they are required to play? What you have described a team with very little upside with many limitations. A variety of styles would cause them no end of trouble. From what you...

I suppose this was the Tahs version of "let's win this one for the Gipper" Talk about just going through the motions... I hope they do not score another try this year. I am hoping they get lapped by the Brumbies. Anything but a false dawn please. I would prefer they sack too many than not...

Any player that thinks he is in a position to dictate who may or may not coach him, when the win/loss is less than 1/3 can fuck off for a start.

Lee the point was not about whether he was worthy of selection, he was clearly selected based on representations from Uni about how well he had been training. No other club has this sort of influence. As you say he looked OK, not OMG he must be picked, which is what you would expect if he had...

Both Frisby and Lucas could play positions other than 9, there was no need to pick Merriman over Donlan based on versatility.After all there must be 6 or 7 variations at least, that would be preferred to Merriman at 10.

Is it possible they know he is looking around?But why get another 9 in any event. They have Hart in the EPS, Merriman in the Academy and then there is Donlan from the Rats in the shadows somewhere as well. It's fucking raining 9's and we are still shopping for more!?

What about Sam Jeffries, plays 20 min ALL year and makes the squad. I make no comment on his ability, just making the point that had he played with any other club he would have zero chance of touring. given his playing record over 2 years, together with his resume.

I just don't get that mentality that anything Mungo is deficient. Yes I prefer this game, yes I see things I don't like in Mungo. But is it all bad with no redeeming features? Don't think so. Some of the comments in this thread are really quite immature.