Vid analysis: Driving me rucking crazy

Vid analysis: Driving me rucking crazy

Adjudicating the match between the Wallabies and France last Saturday was a random penalty generator, otherwise known as David Pearson.

Some of his decisions were mystifying, but there was one pretty early on that truly pissed me off and it’s in the video below.

It’s not the inconsistency that shits me as much as the complete pointlessness of these penalties. Even if you say Horwill went off his feet (I’d say he cleared out the French #5) who the fuck is he sealing off from accessing the ball? Sharpe behind him doesn’t even go off his feet, he’s bound to the nearest man in the ruck.

There’s no contenst for the ball that’s stifled, all it does is kill perfectly good, fast attacking ball and stuff up a game of footy. It almost makes you think the Mungos have a point. Almost.


Matt started G&GR just before the 2007 Rugby World Cup and has been enslaved ever since. Follow him on twitter: @MattRowley

More in France

  • Monday’s Rugby News – 18/11/21

    Welcome to the GAGR News for Monday, folks! Another quiet weekend; however, my own anticipation of the...

  • Monday’s Rugby News – 04/10/21

    Welcome to Monday’s Rugby News, friends! Wowee, what a way to finish The Rugby Championship! The DDFs v Nearlies put on a game for the ages and certainly left me struggling to sleep afterwards. Our lads in G&G defeated Los Pumas relatively convincingly; however, there were still systemic problems in terms of...

  • Monday’s Rugby News- 16th August 2021

    Green And Gold Rugby · The Dropped Kick-Off 26 – Blissful Ignorance   Here I was thinking,...

  • Monday’s Rugby News – 19th July 2021

    Green And Gold Rugby · Rugby Report Card 125 – The Former or the Latter?     Welcome to Monday’s news, GAGRs! I hope you’re all doing well after Saturday’s phenomenal match in Bris-vegas. I, for one, struggled to sleep for a number of hours due to the excitement of the victory!...