• Home
  • Forum
  • Shop
  • Super Rugby
    • ACT Brumbies
    • Melbourne Rebels
    • NSW Waratahs
    • Queensland Reds
    • Western Force
  • Wallabies
    • All Blacks
    • Argentina
    • Barbarians
    • British & Irish Lions
    • England
    • Fiji
    • France
    • Ireland
    • Italy
    • Japan
    • Samoa
    • Scotland
    • Wales
  • Women’s
  • World Cup
    • 2023 Rugby World Cup Fantasy League
  • Sevens
  • Schoolboy
  • Podcast

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

What's Hot

Nutta on the loose: tackling and an open letter from RA

December 1, 2023

Can we all play together?

November 30, 2023

Moneyball.

November 29, 2023
Facebook Instagram YouTube X (Twitter)
Green & Gold Rugby
0 Shopping Cart
Facebook Instagram YouTube X (Twitter)
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Shop
  • Super Rugby
    1. ACT Brumbies
    2. Melbourne Rebels
    3. NSW Waratahs
    4. Queensland Reds
    5. Western Force
    6. View All

    Friday’s Rugby News – 23/6/23

    June 22, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 12/6/23

    June 11, 2023

    Friday’s Rugby News – 9/6/23

    June 9, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 5/6/23

    June 4, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 5/6/23

    June 4, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 29/5/23

    May 28, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 15/5/23

    May 14, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 8/5/23

    May 7, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 5/6/23

    June 4, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 29/5/23

    May 28, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 15/5/23

    May 14, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 8/5/23

    May 7, 2023

    The Reds narrowly defeat the Wild Knights

    November 5, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 5/6/23

    June 4, 2023

    Thursdays Rugby News 1/6/23

    June 1, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 29/5/23

    May 28, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 5/6/23

    June 4, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 29/5/23

    May 28, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 15/5/23

    May 14, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 8/5/23

    May 7, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday’s Rugby News – A New Dawn

    November 23, 2023

    The Chewsday Chew – anything on LinkedIn?

    November 21, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #16: Roll Up, Roll Up.

    November 20, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #15: Who Dares Wins, unless you’re Rugby Australia.

    November 13, 2023
  • Wallabies
    1. All Blacks
    2. Argentina
    3. Barbarians
    4. British & Irish Lions
    5. England
    6. Fiji
    7. France
    8. Ireland
    9. Italy
    10. Japan
    11. Samoa
    12. Scotland
    13. Wales
    14. View All

    In from the side – one Kiwi’s view of the final and some musings (opinion) on where the game’s at.

    November 2, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #14: There can only be one.

    October 30, 2023

    Final Live Review: New Zealand v South Africa -Saturday 28 October

    October 28, 2023

    The Chewsday Chew – Brotherhood

    October 24, 2023

    Friday’s Rugby News: Love thy Neighbour?

    October 19, 2023

    Happy and Crescent’s Thursday Rugby News – Broken Faith

    October 19, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #13: RWC Quarter Finals and Australian Coaching Shenanigans!

    October 16, 2023

    Friday’s Rugby News: ‘Banzai’

    October 12, 2023

    Thursday’s Rugby News 25/5/23

    May 25, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 15/11/21

    November 15, 2021

    Monday’s Rugby News – 20/09/21

    September 20, 2021

    Five observations from the Barbarian match

    November 4, 2014

    Thursdays Rugby News 1/6/23

    June 1, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 13/3/23

    March 12, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 20/09/21

    September 20, 2021

    Thursdays Rugby News

    August 19, 2021

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #13: And then there were Two!

    October 23, 2023

    Game Review: England v South Africa – Semi-Final 2 – Saturday 21 October

    October 22, 2023

    Friday’s Rugby News: Love thy Neighbour?

    October 19, 2023

    Happy and Crescent’s Thursday Rugby News – Broken Faith

    October 19, 2023

    Happy and Crescent’s Thursday Rugby News – Broken Faith

    October 19, 2023

    Friday’s Rugby News: ‘Banzai’

    October 12, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – Anti Wallaby XV (XXIII)

    October 5, 2023

    Game Review: Fiji v Georgia – Pool C – Saturday 30th September

    October 1, 2023

    Happy and Crescent’s Thursday Rugby News – Broken Faith

    October 19, 2023

    Game Pre/Review: France v South Africa – Quarter-Final 4 – Sunday 15 October

    October 15, 2023

    Friday’s Rugby News: ‘Banzai’

    October 12, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #12: And so the Pool Games come to a close!

    October 9, 2023

    Happy Thursday Rugby News – The RWC Myth

    October 26, 2023

    Happy and Crescent’s Thursday Rugby News – Broken Faith

    October 19, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #13: RWC Quarter Finals and Australian Coaching Shenanigans!

    October 16, 2023

    Friday’s Rugby News: ‘Banzai’

    October 12, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – The Best of the Rest

    October 12, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #12: And so the Pool Games come to a close!

    October 9, 2023

    Review: France v Italy – Pool A – 6 October 2023

    October 7, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #10: Did we just see the Final?

    September 25, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #15: Who Dares Wins, unless you’re Rugby Australia.

    November 13, 2023

    The Reds narrowly defeat the Wild Knights

    November 5, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – The Best of the Rest

    October 12, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #12: And so the Pool Games come to a close!

    October 9, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #12: And so the Pool Games come to a close!

    October 9, 2023

    Game Pre/Review: Japan v Samoa – Pool D – Thursday 28 September

    September 28, 2023

    Game Review: Argentina v Samoa – Pool D – Friday 22 September

    September 22, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #9: David v Goliath

    September 18, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – Changing the Narrative

    November 9, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – The Best of the Rest

    October 12, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #12: And so the Pool Games come to a close!

    October 9, 2023

    Ireland v Scotland: Live Chat

    October 8, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday’s Rugby News – A New Dawn

    November 23, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #13: RWC Quarter Finals and Australian Coaching Shenanigans!

    October 16, 2023

    Friday’s Rugby News: ‘Banzai’

    October 12, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #12: And so the Pool Games come to a close!

    October 9, 2023

    The Chewsday Chew – anything on LinkedIn?

    November 21, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #16: Roll Up, Roll Up.

    November 20, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #15: Who Dares Wins, unless you’re Rugby Australia.

    November 13, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – Schadenfreude

    November 2, 2023
  • Women’s

    A personal view

    November 27, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday’s Rugby News – A New Dawn

    November 23, 2023

    WXV 2023 Weekend 3 results

    October 30, 2023

    WXV 2023 Weekend 2 results

    October 22, 2023

    WXV Weekend One Results

    October 17, 2023
  • World Cup
    1. 2023 Rugby World Cup Fantasy League
    2. View All

    Nutta on the loose: tackling and an open letter from RA

    December 1, 2023

    Can we all play together?

    November 30, 2023

    Moneyball.

    November 29, 2023

    The Chewsday Chew – here’s to the ‘grassrooters’.

    November 28, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #16: Roll Up, Roll Up.

    November 20, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #15: Who Dares Wins, unless you’re Rugby Australia.

    November 13, 2023

    2023 RWC Team Ratings

    November 8, 2023

    The Chewsday Chew – RWC23 Team of the Tourney

    November 7, 2023
  • Sevens

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – Changing the Narrative

    November 9, 2023

    Australia’s Iona College brave but beaten in Rugby Heritage Cup Final

    September 7, 2023

    Brisbane’s Iona College through to the world semi-finals of Rugby Heritage Cup

    September 6, 2023

    Happy Thursdays Rugby News 27/7/23

    July 27, 2023

    Thursday’s Rugby News 20/3/23

    April 20, 2023
  • Schoolboy

    Nudgee College win 44th QLD GPS Rugby Premiership

    September 14, 2023

    Thursday’s Rugby News 24/3/22

    March 23, 2022

    Rugbycology report -Super Rugby AU Round 6

    August 10, 2020

    It all starts with ambition: A schools rugby analysis piece

    August 4, 2019

    Australian Schools Championships – the tradition continues

    July 4, 2019
  • Podcast

    The Dropped Kick-Off 103 – McLennan falls in Coup de Tah

    November 20, 2023

    The Dropped Kick-Off 102 – Upsetting Municipal Councils (+ RWC 2023 GF) w Yowie

    October 24, 2023

    The Dropped Kick-Off 101 – A Little Bit Of Chaos w Happyman

    October 12, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – The Best of the Rest

    October 12, 2023

    The Dropped Kick-Off 100 – Here Comes The Fozz w KARL (World Cup Bites II)

    October 6, 2023
Green & Gold Rugby
Home»Super Rugby»NSW Waratahs»Try or No Try?
NSW Waratahs

Try or No Try?

Scott AllenBy Scott AllenApril 27, 201149 Comments1 Views
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr WhatsApp VKontakte Email
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

There’s been lots of comment on the Tom Carter no-try decision on Saturday night. People have strong views on the subject.

Here’s the footage of the movement from three different angles.

[youtube width=”600″ height=”450″]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Km7XMyNG3rM[/youtube]

As a starting point for my analysis I’ve summarised the comments of those who believe the wrong decision was made as follows.

  1. The referee was in poor position or the wrong position to make a decision;
  2. Even if it wasn’t a try, the ensuing scrum should have been awarded to the Waratahs;
  3. Even if the footage doesn’t show the ball being grounded over the line, there were so many Waratahs players over the line that it was obvious that the ball must have been over the line;
  4. If the footage was inconclusive the benefit of the doubt should have been given to the attacking team.

Not everyone who believes it was a try has said all of those things; some have made other points, and some have said it differently, but those four points seem to be the crux of the argument.

Let me address each of those points.

Positioning of the Referee

In the following clip you can see the referee moves around at the rear of the maul so he can keep sight of the ball.

[youtube width=”600″ height=”450″]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XpHS175xgNk[/youtube]

The first thing the referee needs to make a decision on was whether the ball was grounded. Only then does he need to determine whether that grounding was on or over the try line.

I don’t see where else the referee could have positioned himself to see the ball any better, and when it got close to the line he moved to the side to see whether the try line had been crossed.

I think the referee was in a good enough position to make a decision.

The Feed at the Ensuing Scrum

Law 22.10 says:

“When a player carrying the ball is held up in the in-goal so that the player cannot ground the ball, the ball is dead.  A 5-metre scrum is formed. This would apply if play similar to a maul takes place in-goal.  The attacking team throws in the ball.”

If the ball crossed the line but was not grounded then under Law 22.10 a 5 metre scrum should have been awarded with the attacking team, the Waratahs, being awarded the feed.

However, if the ball didn’t cross the line that law does not apply and instead we need to look at Law 17.6.

Law 17.6 (b) says:

“A maul ends unsuccessfully if the ball becomes unplayable or collapses (not as a result of foul play) and a scrum is ordered.”

Law 17.6 (c) then says:

“Scrum following maul. The ball is thrown in by the team not in possession when the maul began.  If the referee cannot decide which team had possession, the team moving forward before the maul stopped throws in the ball.  If neither team was moving forward, the attacking team throws in the ball.”

There is no doubt the Waratahs took the ball into the maul.

Law 17.6 (f) also says:

“When the ball in a maul becomes unplayable, the referee does not allow prolonged wrestling for it.  A scrum is ordered.”

Neither the referee nor the TMO believed the ball had crossed the line, and if that is correct, they were looking at a maul, which had collapsed.

It’s also pretty clear that the ball became unplayable immediately the maul collapsed and the decision made by the referee was correct under Law 17.6.

As to whether the ball crossed the line or not, read on.

Did the Ball Cross the Line?

The footage and images I’m about to refer to are obviously easier to see on a large screen where there’s been no compression required to get the clip down to a suitable size and format for the Internet and You Tube. So if you can’t see the ball in the clip, I’ll have to ask you to take my word for it that on a big screen in digital format you can see the ball.

Tom Carter was carrying the ball under his right arm while he was still on his feet, as shown here:

Image 1

When he first went off his feet he placed the ball down on top of other players and well short of the line, as shown in the following image.

Image 2

He then shifted the ball to his left side and was successful in grounding the ball but again well short of the line, as shown in this image:

Image 3

To make sure I’ve not confused the ball with a boot, I’ve identified the boots / legs of the players around the ball here.

Image 4

He then advanced the ball again and 19/25ths of a second later grounded the ball again, which we can see from the rear view.

Image 5

It’s easier to see the ball when it’s moving so I’ve slowed the footage from each of the angles and highlighted where the ball is in the following clip.

[youtube width=”600″ height=”450″]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hu9FuV-WXVQ[/youtube]

The challenge with this analysis is to determine whether, on the second grounding of the ball, there is any evidence of whether it was grounded before the try line, on the try line or over it.

The first thing to look for is a reference point between all the angles we have of the moment that the ball was grounded. In the following clip watch the movement of Greg Holmes as he gets to his feet.

[youtube width=”600″ height=”450″]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wSYnvVStO0U[/youtube]

In Image number 5 above from the rear view you can see the ball on the ground, and you can see that Holmes’s leg is parallel to the ground at that particular moment.

In the following image you can also see that Holmes’s leg is parallel to the ground, so this is the same moment.

Image 6

Again, in this image from the side view his leg is also parallel to the ground, so this is also the same moment.

Image 7

So we now have three views of the moment the ball was grounded the second time.

If we return to Image number 5 above, where you can see the ball grounded, you can also see that the ball has been placed against Carter’s left thigh. You can also see Luke Burgess has his hands close to the ball as he reaches in trying to pick it up.  That gives us the first clue as to whether the ball is grounded on the try line or over it: if it is, why is Burgess attempting to pick it up? Why wouldn’t he instead be pointing to the ball to let the referee know he can see it grounded on or over the try line? There is no way we can answer that question, so we’ll have to look at what other evidence there is.

Of course the problem with Image number 5 above is that it’s shot from the rear and we cannot see the try line.

So let’s look at Image number 6 above, where we can’t see the ball or the position of Carter’s left thigh. The thing this shot is useful for is to show where Burgess’s hands are. We know his hands were very close to the ball at that particular moment and this shot shows that his hands are quite some distance away from the try line.

Image number 7 above from the side angle is more helpful. At the very moment that the ball is grounded it’s obvious that Burgess’s hands are well short of the try line. What we don’t know for sure is how far in front of Burgess’s hands the ball was.

However, the time difference between the side view where we can see the ball on the ground and the rear view when we see it being grounded again, is only 19/25ths of a second. To see how quickly the ball would have had to advance from the first point it was on the ground to the try line at the moment we can see it being grounded for the second time, I’ve added the outline of a ball to the side on view as shown in the following clip.

[youtube width=”600″ height=”450″]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JZYdRZqfe84[/youtube]

While my graphics showing the movement of the ball are a little basic, they illustrate how far the ball would have had to travel in such a short time to even end up on the line. It doesn’t look plausible that Carter was able to advance it that far, that quickly.

This isn’t conclusive proof, but I think it shows that if you had to make a decision, it’s more likely that the ball was grounded short of the try line rather than on or over the try line.

But there was some doubt in the referee’s mind and accordingly he asked the TMO for assistance.

What About Benefit of the Doubt Going to the Attacking Team?

The concept of Benefit of the Doubt does not exist in Rugby Union.

The laws regarding the TMO do not mention what should occur if the referee or the TMO has doubts about a decision.

Therefore there was no benefit of the doubt to be applied as there is in Cricket or in Rugby League.

Conclusion

So, did the referee make the right decision?

  • He was in a good enough position to make the decision;
  • While the TMO confirmed it was inconclusive as to whether a try had been scored, he did confirm he could see no evidence that the ball had crossed the try line;
  • I think the evidence I’ve shown you supports the proposition that the ball was short of the try line;
  • As the TMO could not give him a definite answer the referee was required to make a decision based on what he believed had occurred;
  • The fact that he decided the maul had become unplayable, rather than that the ball had been held up in-goa,l shows that he believed that the ball had not crossed the try line.

Having decided that the ball was short of the try line he made the correct decision in ruling that it was a collapsed maul where the ball had become unplayable ,and it was the defensive team’s feed into the scrum.

Analysis Opinion reds Rugby Super Rugby tom carter Video Analysis Waratahs
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr WhatsApp Email
Previous ArticleThe Crooked Feed: 27 April 2011
Next Article Bloem’s Brüssow back for bruised Brumbies bash
Scott Allen
  • X (Twitter)

Scott is one of our regular contributors from the old days of G&GR. He has experience coaching Premier Grade with two clubs in Brisbane.

Related Posts

Can we all play together?

November 30, 2023

Moneyball.

November 29, 2023

The Chewsday Chew – here’s to the ‘grassrooters’.

November 28, 2023

A personal view

November 27, 2023
GAGR Podcast
Our Picks

A personal view

November 27, 2023

Moneyball.

November 29, 2023

Can we all play together?

November 30, 2023

The Chewsday Chew – here’s to the ‘grassrooters’.

November 28, 2023
Follow Us
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
Don't Miss
Australia

Nutta on the loose: tackling and an open letter from RA

By NuttaDecember 1, 202340

Hello all. In my inbox this morning: “…the tackle height will be lowered to below…

Can we all play together?

November 30, 2023

Moneyball.

November 29, 2023

The Chewsday Chew – here’s to the ‘grassrooters’.

November 28, 2023

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news from Green & Gold Rugby.

About Us
About Us

greenandgoldrugby.com is your one stop shop for all things Rugby Union - news, podcasts, opinions, fixtures, events & everything in between.

greenandgoldrugby.com - created by fans of rugby, for fans of rugby.

About
Submit a Story
Authors
Contact
Privacy

Our Picks

A personal view

November 27, 2023

Moneyball.

November 29, 2023

Can we all play together?

November 30, 2023
New Comments
  • Patrick on Nutta on the loose: tackling and an open letter from RA
  • Eloise Pasteur on Nutta on the loose: tackling and an open letter from RA
  • Red Block on Nutta on the loose: tackling and an open letter from RA
  • Rod Finnegan on Nutta on the loose: tackling and an open letter from RA
  • Walt White on Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #15: Who Dares Wins, unless you’re Rugby Australia.
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Super Rugby
  • Wallabies
  • Podcast
  • Privacy Policy (2023)
© 2023 Ponderosa Publishing Pty Ltd | ABN 76 668 430 386.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.