• Home
  • Forum
  • Super Rugby
    • ACT Brumbies
    • Melbourne Rebels
    • NSW Waratahs
    • Queensland Reds
    • Western Force
  • Wallabies
    • All Blacks
    • Argentina
    • Barbarians
    • British & Irish Lions
    • England
    • Fiji
    • France
    • Ireland
    • Italy
    • Japan
    • Samoa
    • Scotland
    • Wales
  • Women’s Rugby
  • Rugby World Cup
    • 2023 Rugby World Cup Fantasy League
  • Sevens
  • Schoolboy
  • Podcast

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

What's Hot

Game Review: England v Chile – Pool D – Saturday 23 September

September 24, 2023

Game Review: Georgia v Portugal – Pool C – Saturday, 23 September

September 24, 2023

Game Review: South Africa v Ireland – Pool B – Saturday, 23 September

September 24, 2023
Facebook Instagram YouTube Twitter
Green and Gold Rugby
Facebook Instagram YouTube Twitter
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Super Rugby
    1. ACT Brumbies
    2. Melbourne Rebels
    3. NSW Waratahs
    4. Queensland Reds
    5. Western Force
    6. View All

    Friday’s Rugby News – 23/6/23

    June 22, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 12/6/23

    June 11, 2023

    Friday’s Rugby News – 9/6/23

    June 9, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 5/6/23

    June 4, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 5/6/23

    June 4, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 29/5/23

    May 28, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 15/5/23

    May 14, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 8/5/23

    May 7, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 5/6/23

    June 4, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 29/5/23

    May 28, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 15/5/23

    May 14, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 8/5/23

    May 7, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 5/6/23

    June 4, 2023

    Thursdays Rugby News 1/6/23

    June 1, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 29/5/23

    May 28, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 15/5/23

    May 14, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 5/6/23

    June 4, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 29/5/23

    May 28, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 15/5/23

    May 14, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 8/5/23

    May 7, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News –Eddie Jones Is the Answer for Australian Rugby

    August 24, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – The Chocolate Wheel of Injustice

    August 17, 2023

    Thursdays Rugby News – May the Force Be With Them

    August 10, 2023

    Happy Thursday – Its Not a Conspiracy If They Are Picking On You

    August 3, 2023
  • Wallabies
    1. All Blacks
    2. Argentina
    3. Barbarians
    4. British & Irish Lions
    5. England
    6. Fiji
    7. France
    8. Ireland
    9. Italy
    10. Japan
    11. Samoa
    12. Scotland
    13. Wales
    14. View All

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #9: David v Goliath

    September 18, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #8: Let’s Get ready to rumble!

    September 11, 2023

    Game Review: France v New Zealand – Pool A – Friday 8 September

    September 9, 2023

    Friday’s Rugby News: C’est l’heure.

    September 8, 2023

    Game Review: Argentina v Samoa – Pool D – Friday 22 September

    September 22, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – Week Two What Did We Learn

    September 21, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #8: Let’s Get ready to rumble!

    September 11, 2023

    Game Review: England v Argentina – Pool D – Saturday 9 September

    September 10, 2023

    Thursday’s Rugby News 25/5/23

    May 25, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 15/11/21

    November 15, 2021

    Monday’s Rugby News – 20/09/21

    September 20, 2021

    Five observations from the Barbarian match

    November 4, 2014

    Thursdays Rugby News 1/6/23

    June 1, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 13/3/23

    March 12, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 20/09/21

    September 20, 2021

    Thursdays Rugby News

    August 19, 2021

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – Week Two What Did We Learn

    September 21, 2023

    Live Chat: England v Japan.

    September 18, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #9: David v Goliath

    September 18, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #8: Let’s Get ready to rumble!

    September 11, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – Week Two What Did We Learn

    September 21, 2023

    Eddie Has to Go!

    September 18, 2023

    Live Chat & Game Review: Fiji v Australia – Pool D – Sunday 8 October

    September 18, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #9: David v Goliath

    September 18, 2023

    France v Namibia – Pool A – Thursday 21 September

    September 22, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – Week Two What Did We Learn

    September 21, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #9: David v Goliath

    September 18, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #8: Let’s Get ready to rumble!

    September 11, 2023

    South Africa v Ireland: Live Chat

    September 24, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – Week Two What Did We Learn

    September 21, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #9: David v Goliath

    September 18, 2023

    Live Chat: Ireland v Tonga

    September 17, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #9: David v Goliath

    September 18, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #8: Let’s Get ready to rumble!

    September 11, 2023

    The Chewsday Chew

    April 10, 2023

    Thursday’s Rugby News 16/3/23

    March 16, 2023

    Live Chat: England v Japan.

    September 18, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #9: David v Goliath

    September 18, 2023

    Game Review: Japan v Chile – Pool D – Sunday 10 September

    September 10, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #7: It’s the Final Countdown!

    September 4, 2023

    Game Review: Argentina v Samoa – Pool D – Friday 22 September

    September 22, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #9: David v Goliath

    September 18, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 18th July 2022

    July 17, 2022

    Monday’s Rugby News – 11th July 2022

    July 10, 2022

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #9: David v Goliath

    September 18, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #8: Let’s Get ready to rumble!

    September 11, 2023

    Live Chat: South Africa v Scotland

    September 11, 2023

    Thursday’s Rugby News 9/2/23

    February 9, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #9: David v Goliath

    September 18, 2023

    Game Review: Fiji v Wales – Pool C – Sunday 10 September

    September 11, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #8: Let’s Get ready to rumble!

    September 11, 2023

    Live Chat: Wales v Fiji

    September 11, 2023

    Friday’s Rugby News: Utopia?

    September 22, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – Week Two What Did We Learn

    September 21, 2023

    Eddie Has to Go!

    September 18, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #9: David v Goliath

    September 18, 2023
  • Women’s Rugby

    Compare and contrast of AU and NZ women’s rugby

    September 7, 2023

    Friday’s Rugby News: The Gaul of it.

    August 25, 2023

    Kirby Sefo on Women’s Rugby

    August 24, 2023

    Yowie on the Loose: World Cup squads, coach-helpers and some catch-up for women’s rugby

    August 23, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 24/7/23

    July 23, 2023
  • Rugby World Cup
    1. 2023 Rugby World Cup Fantasy League
    2. View All

    Game Review: England v Chile – Pool D – Saturday 23 September

    September 24, 2023

    Game Review: Georgia v Portugal – Pool C – Saturday, 23 September

    September 24, 2023

    Game Review: South Africa v Ireland – Pool B – Saturday, 23 September

    September 24, 2023

    South Africa v Ireland: Live Chat

    September 24, 2023

    Game Review: England v Chile – Pool D – Saturday 23 September

    September 24, 2023

    Game Review: Georgia v Portugal – Pool C – Saturday, 23 September

    September 24, 2023

    Game Review: South Africa v Ireland – Pool B – Saturday, 23 September

    September 24, 2023

    South Africa v Ireland: Live Chat

    September 24, 2023
  • Sevens

    Australia’s Iona College brave but beaten in Rugby Heritage Cup Final

    September 7, 2023

    Brisbane’s Iona College through to the world semi-finals of Rugby Heritage Cup

    September 6, 2023

    Happy Thursdays Rugby News 27/7/23

    July 27, 2023

    Thursday’s Rugby News 20/3/23

    April 20, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 10/4/23

    April 9, 2023
  • Schoolboy Rugby

    Nudgee College win 44th QLD GPS Rugby Premiership

    September 14, 2023

    Thursday’s Rugby News 24/3/22

    March 23, 2022

    Rugbycology report -Super Rugby AU Round 6

    August 10, 2020

    It all starts with ambition: A schools rugby analysis piece

    August 4, 2019

    Australian Schools Championships – the tradition continues

    July 4, 2019
  • Podcast

    The Dropped Kick-Off 97 – Put it in H

    September 20, 2023

    The Dropped Kick-Off 96 – ‘First Gear’ Wallabies (RWC2023 Fiji Preview) with Hoss

    September 15, 2023

    The Dropped Kick-Off 95 – World Cup Bites (RWC2023 Week One) with Hoss

    September 13, 2023

    The Dropped Kick-Off 94 – Your Ultimate 2023 Rugby World Cup Predictor

    September 6, 2023

    The Dropped Kick-Off 91 – A Moral (Oral) Victory

    August 3, 2023
Green and Gold Rugby
Home»Rugby»The High Tackle Framework
Rugby

The High Tackle Framework

KARLBy KARLJune 8, 202152 Comments0 Views
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr WhatsApp VKontakte Email
Jock Campbell
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

Once again team these are my interpretations of the direction provided by World Rugby and passed on by the NSWRRA to me. If I’m wrong, then it’s my learnings that got it wrong.

Rugby, like many contact sports has recognised that there is a lot more it can do to protect the people playing the game. Over the years as more and more science has gone into fitness, nutrition, strength and conditioning players have got bigger and faster with the consequence that the collisions in the game have got harder. People are also starting to take note of the effects of these collisions, especially the ones to the head and the long-term effect of this on the players. While there is undoubtably an element of arse covering in this where administrators are able to say “we did all we could do with the knowledge we had at the time” I think the prime aim is actually to protect the players and to ensure that they don’t have long term issues resulting from playing rugby. I still believe the people managing this game do care about the people as much as the product and that they understand protecting them is a good idea. A big change has been to try and reduce the high tackle by penalising those who make contact with the head.

World Rugby has put out a framework for managing these high tackles and the framework tries to take into account the dynamics of the game. In most cases it is good with the main issue being that a referee has to apply this framework in the length of time it took you to read this sentence.
The initial part is quite clear:

I. Is the incident a high tackle or a shoulder charge?
II. If so, was there contact with the head or neck of the ball carrier?
III. Was the degree of danger high or low?
IV. Are there any clear and obvious mitigating factors?

Now every tackle is a tackler driving his shoulder into the ball carrier. In my case when I was playing, with as much force as possible to stop the player and make him drop the ball. However, the clear aim of a tackle is to stop and then grab the ball carrier, so the arms must be in a position to reach around the player and should be in motion during the tackle. This is often noticed where a referee will say “There was no arms in the tackle!” Clearly the aim of that tackle was not to get the ball but to stop the ball carrier.

Moeroa high tackle
Moeroa high tackle

A shoulder charge is defined as where “the arm of the shoulder making contact behind the tacklers body or tucked in a “sling” position at the point of contact.” To be honest I don’t usually have any issues with this one and in most cases, it is pretty clear.

A high tackle is a bit more complex and is defined as “An illegal tackle causing head contact, where head contact is identified by clear contact to the ball carrier head/neck OR the head visibly moves backwards from the contact point, OR the ball carrier requires an HIA” This one for me carries a lot more subjectivity, not because it isn’t clear, but because there is so much to it.

During a game I personally just call anything high and penalise, especially early as I find that way most players adapt quickly and then stay low. I also include it in my pre-match talk to the captain, so he/she knows I’m looking out for it. The next bit of this is the analysis that is done about the tackle, and this is where it can get complicated. The rulings in the guideline are very clear:

 

A Shoulder Charge
• If there is contact with the head – Red Card
• If there is no contact with the head, but it is a dangerous tackle – Yellow Card
• If there is no head contact and low danger – Penalty only

A High Tackle
There are two areas to initially look at. Firstly, was the contact to the Ball Carrier with the tacklers head or shoulder?
• High contact with tacklers shoulder or head and high danger – Red Card
• High contact with tacklers shoulder or head and low danger – Yellow Card
Secondly, was the contact to the Ball Carrier with the tacklers arm?
• High contact with tacklers arm to head or neck with high danger – Red Card
• High contact with tacklers arm to head or neck with low danger – Yellow Card
• No direct contact to the head but a tackle over or above the shoulder “seat belt tackle – Penalty

Some of the signs that there is likely to be a high level of danger include:
• Tackler drawing the arm back before contact
• Tackler leaving the ground
• Arm swinging forward prior to contact
• Tackle is an active or dominant tackle rather than a passive or the tackler pulls out on contact
• The Tackler accelerates into the tackle
• The Tackler follows through the tackle rather than pulling out of it

So far so good and pretty clear and obvious. It looks messy but to be honest I don’t have too much problem with any of this and in most cases it’s pretty clear even if some of it can be very subjective.

Mitigation

This appears to be where there is the most confusion and certainly where some most commentators really get it wrong. I’ll cover this in a bit of depth as this seems to be the most contentious area. Note: Any mitigation factor can only lower the penalty by one step, so a red card offence can go to yellow not to a penalty.

Factors against Mitigation
Not something often considered but if the tackler and the ball carrier are in clear open space and the tackler has a clear line of sight and/or time before the tackle it is unlikely that any mitigating factors will be applied. The reason behind this is that it is the tacklers responsibility to tackle safely, and in this situation, they can clearly prepare themselves for the tackle.

Factors for Mitigation.

These must be clear and obvious factors and as this is sometimes a matter of perception, they can seem very subjective. As a referee it means to me is that unless the picture shows something deliberate then it is unlikely to be that clear and obvious.

Ball carrier dropping their height: This seems to be the one that most people pick up on and there are two parts to it. Apart from a few Wallaby locks, all ball carriers will drop when they confront a tackler so a player going down in height is not unexpected and therefore not usually a factor. However, if the drop is a sudden drop due to the player tripping or falling, from an earlier tackle or diving to score then it is a factor to take into consideration.
Tackler makes a definite attempt to change height in an effort to avoid the ball carrier’s head: This has to be a clear and obvious effort and is usually where a tackler attempts to pull out of the tackle when they see they may have it wrong. No worries with it but it must be “clear and obvious” and that’s the hard part both to do and to rule on.
Tackler is unsighted prior to contact: If a player is attempting to tackle and the ball carrier moves behind another player as the tackler moves in and can then not see the ball carrier this may be a mitigating factor.
Reactionary tackle with immediate release: We all know that in a game sometimes you just react to something, usually by reaching out and for some reason this is usually high. If the tackler clearly does this and immediately pulls out, then it is a factor to be taken into consideration.
Indirect contact – starts elsewhere and then moves up: This does happen a lot and is a clear mitigating factor.

As you can see, there is quite a lot to this and noting my previous comment about the length of time there is to make a decision it is understandable why there is sometimes some contention about the application of the law. Having suffered concussions in a couple of games I am more than happy with the emphasis on looking after the players welfare. I think that as we have seen over the last few years the players and coaches are adjusting their play for the new reality just as they have for other law changes. It takes a few penalties and cards for them to get it right, but most are adaptable and will make the effort. Personally, I think that if a player or a coach is too stupid, or too arrogant to change then both should move out of the game and go and play another sport.

Despite some people saying things like “it’s making the game soft” or “wasn’t like that in my day” or other such meaningless dribble the game does need to change with the times. We are losing kids before they even start with parents wanting a safer environment for their kids to play and if you see some of the ex-players and how they are suffering from the effects of head knocks then I think most normal people will understand and embrace the changes. While there will always be accidents and while there is a need for personal responsibility to remain safe, if we want this great game to grow then we need to make these sorts of changes.

News
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr WhatsApp Email
Previous ArticleTuesday’s Rugby News
Next Article Wednesday’s Rugby News
KARL

Born in NZ and emigrated to Australia to be with my Australian wife I met whilst serving in the NZ Army. Proud to be an Australian by choice as well as a Kiwi. After more than 32 years in the NZ Army I am a huge believer in ANZAC. My dream is to see NZ No 1 and Australia No2 in world rankings. I played rugby for 43 odd years and have been refereeing for 13 love the game and the camaraderie it generates.

Related Posts

Game Review: South Africa v Ireland – Pool B – Saturday, 23 September

September 24, 2023

South Africa v Ireland: Live Chat

September 24, 2023

Game Review: Argentina v Samoa – Pool D – Friday 22 September

September 22, 2023

France v Namibia – Pool A – Thursday 21 September

September 22, 2023
GAGR Podcast
Our Picks

Eddie Has to Go!

September 18, 2023

Live Chat & Game Review: Fiji v Australia – Pool D – Sunday 8 October

September 18, 2023

Friday’s Rugby News: Utopia?

September 22, 2023

Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – Week Two What Did We Learn

September 21, 2023
Follow Us
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
Don't Miss
Rugby World Cup

Game Review: England v Chile – Pool D – Saturday 23 September

By KeithSeptember 24, 20233

Another early morning report from your Tasweigian correspondent. I get all the plum jobs. Hardly…

Game Review: Georgia v Portugal – Pool C – Saturday, 23 September

September 24, 2023

Game Review: South Africa v Ireland – Pool B – Saturday, 23 September

September 24, 2023

South Africa v Ireland: Live Chat

September 24, 2023

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news from Green & Gold Rugby.

About Us
About Us

greenandgoldrugby.com is your one stop shop for all things Rugby Union - news, podcasts, opinions, fixtures, events & everything in between.

greenandgoldrugby.com - created by fans of rugby, for fans of rugby.

About
Submit a Story
Authors
Contact
Privacy

Our Picks

Eddie Has to Go!

September 18, 2023

Live Chat & Game Review: Fiji v Australia – Pool D – Sunday 8 October

September 18, 2023

Friday’s Rugby News: Utopia?

September 22, 2023
New Comments
  • Patrick on Game Review: South Africa v Ireland – Pool B – Saturday, 23 September
  • KwAussie Rugby Lover on Game Review: South Africa v Ireland – Pool B – Saturday, 23 September
  • KwAussie Rugby Lover on Game Review: South Africa v Ireland – Pool B – Saturday, 23 September
  • KwAussie Rugby Lover on Game Review: South Africa v Ireland – Pool B – Saturday, 23 September
  • KwAussie Rugby Lover on Game Review: England v Chile – Pool D – Saturday 23 September
Facebook Twitter Instagram Pinterest
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Super Rugby
  • Wallabies
  • Podcast
  • Privacy Policy (2023)
© 2023 Ponderosa Publishing Pty Ltd | ABN 76 668 430 386.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.