• Welcome to the forums of Green & Gold Rugby.
    We have recently made some changes to the amount of discussions boards on the forum.
    Over the coming months we will continue to make more changes to make the forum more user friendly for all to use.
    Thanks, Admin.

Why "soccer"?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Biffo

Ken Catchpole (46)
The claim of the roundball code to exclusive ownership of the title “football” is erroneous in fact and in history. That claim rests on the assertion that the ball in soccer is played by the foot, whereas in other codes it is played by the hand. The truth is that in soccer the ball is played by any part of the body except the elbow and below. So, the name of the code should be “anywhere but below the elbow ball”.

“Football” is a generic name to distinguish between games played on foot and on horseback and has nothing to do with the mode of play.

Back in the mid 19th century, many sets of rules were used by differing clubs playing games with some similarity to parts of rugby, soccer, gaelic football and the Eton Wall Game. These clubs found it hard to make matches with others because of the variations in rules and set out to solve the problem.

In the 1860s, someone had the very good idea of bringing together the clubs playing various types of game to standardize the rules. This succeeded and then England had two clear codes. Other countries subsequently adopted the same, or very similar, rules for those two codes.

At the 1860s meetings was a group representing clubs who played under rules similar to those which now apply to soccer. This group labelled itself the “Football Association”. The English, as they often do, coined an abbreviated name for this group – “the assocs” which was pronounced with a hard “c”. Quite seamlessly, the assocs were quickly deemed to be playing “soccer” – the game of the assocs.

An interesting development subsequent to the meeting was the naming of the controlling body for England’s rugby – it was the “Rugby Football Union” (my bold). The soccer mob called themselves the "Football Association".
 

Lindommer

Simon Poidevin (60)
Staff member
Biffo said:
...in soccer the ball is played by any part of the body except the elbow and below. So, the name of the code should be “anywhere but below the elbow ball”.

Totally agree. I had an argument with a soccer fan recently when he insisted soccer was the true football game which was played only with the feet. As we all know it isn't: apart from Biffo's remarks above the goalie can use his hands at any time and all players can use their hands throwing the ball in from the sideline.

Football encompasses American Football, Australian Football (there used to be two of these, VFL and VFA), Canadian Football, Gaelic Football, the two rugby codes and Association Football. For one code to presume it is the only football and insist it has exclusive rights to the word "football" is arrogant in the extreme.

For me it's always "soccer".
 

Biffo

Ken Catchpole (46)
It took many years of (very part time) research to find out what I posted above. My motivation was to win arguments against the arrogant usurpers of "football". Then I found it didn't help me - the usurpers just gave me blank looks, too dumb to understand the facts.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top