Sydney Subbies 2024

[21mm]

Agree, hes the best in the business, and does it with no help from secondary pundits to fill dead air.

Subbies need to do a "match of the day" that includes this mans commentary and analysis. Shares the love around between divisions and gets to highlight clubs with that professionalism.

Think "College Game day" in College football in the states.

 

[parkfootyenthusiast2]

Without knowing a lot about the Div 3 clubs Irish, Knox Merrylands, I haven’t seen any of them regularly fielding that 3rd side to show there numbers. Would be a huge step up to compete with the big Div 2 clubs

Yep can't see it happening, all the better div 3 clubs face one major issue or another.

Irish: Could maybe stretch to a third grade side at best (5 games of Halligans), no colts
Knox: Couldn't get 3 grades out
Merrylands:: Couldn't get 3 grades out weekly - though they did play a couple weeks of Halligans, could maybe stretch, but no colts
Valley: Have the numbers, don't have the talent
Harbour: no colts or second grade

They'll have to get creative.

 

[parkfootyenthusiast2]

Excellent commentary job, well done.

Have to second that, the professionalism was great and that call when Newport went over was spectacular. Also enjoyed whoever was on the division 3 play by play.

 

[crushermoran]

Yep can't see it happening, all the better div 3 clubs face one major issue or another.

The Epping option doesn't seem so bad after all.

 

[Pfitzy]

The Colts issue at some clubs could be solved by a better alignment of Community rugby generally.

 

[parkfootyenthusiast2]

In theory I think you'd rather a club like Knox plays Barraclough, Stockdale and Robertson, or Irish plays Barraclough, Stockdale and Blunt than have a repeat of this year's mess. Will leave that one to the decision makers though...

 

[KentwellCup>ShuteShield]

Looks like forest played their last game in Div 1 last weekend, but I guess will be dependant on wether Newport are ready to make the jump up.

As previously mentioned before they've had some numbers problems, which will not fly in Div 1. Any Newport supporters/insiders got any knowledge on their plans? Ashame we might not get to see Forest v Newport derby in a competitive match-up.

Maybe if Newport can't make the jump UNSW might?

 

[Pfitzy]

Difficult when we don't have 8 clubs fitting the varying cookie cutters in each Division.

Having a mixed Division can work but eventually you need clubs to get to the stage where they can make the jump. Evolutionary thinking required.

 

[Crashy]

I think Knox Old Boys have the players to to Div 2 if they get the pipeline from the school going again who I think have 8 grades at school in opens?. Before they imploded they were doing pretty well in Div 1 for a while with 6 teams.
Requires some serious recruitment, strong leadership, fairy dust and luck.

 

[The Ghost of Bernie]

LCOI Colts gave it everything they had. Super proud of the lads who at the start of the season, basically didn't know each others names.

 

[Mule]

LCOI colts gave a valiant effort, but were only in the game due to a heap of discipline issues by Knox in the first half..... once Knox improved their accuracy the floodgates opened....

 

[The Ghost of Bernie]

Certainly agree that the second half was a different story but poor discipline comes generally being under pressure, be that from scrums lost against the feed, dropped balls or a 50/22.

 

[Nath]

It is interesting Burraneer used the strategy of qualifying players from the Wollongong Comp who had played all year there and finished their season. Players scraped through with "2 games" and then popped up in the finals.

Who are these players that have been pinched from Wollongong? Strange one given their comp is still going.

 

[parkfootyenthusiast2]

Turning my attention to div 1 now that 2 and 3 have wrapped, interesting to note this weeks prelim finals are made up solely of 4 clubs: Hunters Hill (2), Waverley (3), Colleagues (5!) and Blue Mountains (2).

Throw in the fact that Blue Mountains (2), HH (1), and Waverley (2) already make up 5 of the 6 GF qualified teams (long live Mosmans dominant Colts outfit), it's certainly shaping up to be a very top heavy Grand Final day next week. Comparatively, a hugely lean year for Forest, Drummoyne, Lindfield and to a lessor extent Mosman.

If the unthinkable happens and Colleagues were to lose their 5 prelim finals... could see a situation where 11/12 grand final teams are from 3 clubs!

Even more interesting to note that Waverley (2016), Hunters Hill (2020) and Blue Mountains (2018) were competing in lower divisions not all that long ago and are now the powerhouses of division 1, full credit to them!

 

[Heavyd]

(long live Mosmans dominant Colts outfit),

I heard a lot of them are Marlins 1st colts from last year who came to play in the under 21 comp with mates before returning back to Marlins next year. I could be of course very wrong. Hopefully they have enjoyed subbies that much that they stick around.

 

[grievous]

I had the honour of commentating the Division Two Grand Finals on Saturday and it was another fantastic day of rugby...

How do you get that gig? With so much club rugby covered on various platforms now commentating must be the only position in rugby booming.

 

[The Wombat]

I heard a lot of them are Marlins 1st colts from last year who came to play in the under 21 comp with mates before returning back to Marlins next year.

Untrue

 

[Eastcoast]

Untrue

I was hearing on Saturday that a few were from Norths Colts. Either way, a strong group of colts.
Game was close on the weekend, but there were a few things that If HH get through this week against a surging Colleagues, I expect that the GF may go the other way.

 

[parkfootyenthusiast2]

I was hearing on Saturday that a few were from Norths Colts. Either way, a strong group of colts.
Game was close on the weekend, but there were a few things that If HH get through this week against a surging Colleagues, I expect that the GF may go the other way.

You said the same thing about first grade... I love your optimism EC!

 

[Eastcoast]

You said the same thing about first grade... I love your optimism EC!

Finals time is the best time of year. Weather for both this weekend and next week looks outstanding.
Concord oval looks in great condition for the next two weeks as well.

Will have Prelim final tips out first thing tomorrow morning!