• Welcome to the forums of Green & Gold Rugby.
    We have recently made some changes to the amount of discussions boards on the forum.
    Over the coming months we will continue to make more changes to make the forum more user friendly for all to use.
    Thanks, Admin.

Horwill gone for 2012

Status
Not open for further replies.

Lindommer

Simon Poidevin (60)
Staff member
In today's Oz: http://www.theaustralian.com.au/spo...-again-this-year/story-e6frg7o6-1226391584897

WALLABIES captain James Horwill will consult a Melbourne specialist tomorrow about his injured hamstring but has ruled out playing again for the Queensland Reds this season and admits he may not play again before next year.

It appeared last week that surgery had been ruled out as a way of repairing the hamstring he hyperextended when a ruck collapsed on top of him in the Reds' crucial win over the Brumbies on May 26 but Horwill said yesterday that option was back on the table. "We're still discussing the best course of action but hopefully I'll have a clearer idea after getting another opinion from this Melbourne specialist on hamstrings," Horwill said. "I can't see myself playing for the Reds again this year which is a shame because we have three pretty important games to play to get into the Super Rugby finals. I'm told the length of the recovery time in these types of cases is very much dependent on the individual but most people are advising me it will be three to six months. At this stage we're hoping there is no need for surgery but the main issue is to just get it right."

Horwill has his fingers crossed that he will miss only the early rounds of the Rugby Championship, the old Tri-Nations expanded this year to include Argentina. The tournament opens on August 18 with a Test against the All Blacks in Sydney and runs until October 8 when Australia plays the Pumas in Rosario. "The worst-case scenario is that I'm out for the rest of the year. I'd like to play as early as I can but if it's no good I've just got to spend the time getting it right."

Horwill's grim prognosis makes it imperative that Wallabies coach Robbie Deans takes veteran lock Nathan Sharpe aside for a chat probably both of them were hoping to avoid. Sharpe, 33, intends to make his farewell professional rugby appearance in Christchurch on July 14 when the Western Force plays its final Super Rugby match against the Crusaders and that remains his plan. He made himself available for the three-Test series against Wales to help tide the Wallabies over but he has hinted that should Deans need him to defer his retirement until the end of the Rugby Championship, he would seriously consider any request. Sharpe may no longer be quite as dynamic as he once was but the 103-Test veteran delivers a bankable performance every time he plays and his contribution to Australia's 27-19 victory over Wales in Brisbane was considerable. Although Australia has some brilliant young locks on the rise, Deans surely would be hoping to avoid going in against the All Blacks, Springboks and Pumas with only young locks Rob Simmons, Sitaleki Timani, and uncapped Rebels pair Cadeyrn Neville and Hugh Pyle to call upon.

The other factor Deans will need to weigh up is that the longer Horwill remains on the sideline, the more difficult it will be realistically for him to return to the Wallabies captaincy if David Pocock continues to lead the side as dynamically as he did in Brisbane. Pocock yesterday brushed aside the question of whether he had any immediate designs on taking on the job permanently, not just as caretaker. "I'm enjoying it at the moment, but nothing's changed," Pocock said. "James Horwill is captain of the Wallabies and I'm standing in for him while he's injured."

Tighthead Sekope Kepu remained with the Wallabies in Melbourne yesterday, suggesting his hand injury may not be as serious as first feared, while Kurtley Beale took part in what was a glorified fitness run for the non-starters in Brisbane. His prospects of returning to the Test side, probably via the bench, on Saturday hinge on the outcome of the investigation into the incident involving him and Quade Cooper at the Victory Hotel in Brisbane last Friday.




FFFFAAAARRRRKKKKK!
 

Hugh Jarse

Rocky Elsom (76)
That is not good news for the Reds, Wobs and more importantly the Horwills.

I have always said that all professional athletes are only one bad hamstring away from the dole queue if they do not have an potential alternative source of income like a trade or profession away from the game.

Let's hope that recovery is uncomplicated, and he returns fully intact and raring to go.
 

biggsy

Chilla Wilson (44)
Playing Rugby might look like pocket money from what his Family trust might look like...

He will be back
 

Aussie D

Desmond Connor (43)
This makes Deans' decision not to select a specialist lock on the bench even more short-sighted with the impending retirement of Nathan Sharpe. He could use the last two tests against the Welsh to blood one of the young locks off the bench before the commencement of TRC. I don't want the Wallabies to be potentially blooding two rookie locks to partner the relativey inexperienced Simmons in that series.
 

FrankLind

Colin Windon (37)
This is a big loss. Horwill is your best lock, best captain, a great all-round player, and a good guy too.

Sharpe can hang on for this season, but I see Simmons as a bit of a lightweight still.
Where is Vickerman - injured/retired??
 

Reddy!

Bob Davidson (42)
Wow, unfortunate, but good on Sharpe for still being there when last year it was quite clear he was out of favour with Deans.
 

Sandpit Fan

Nev Cottrell (35)
This is a big loss. Horwill is your best lock, best captain, a great all-round player, and a good guy too.

Sharpe can hang on for this season, but I see Simmons as a bit of a lightweight still.
Where is Vickerman - injured/retired??

Agree with that. Vickerman is knocking on the door of the knackers yard, he hasn't turned a wheel for the whole S15 season due to injury and even if he magically came right wouldn't be match fit.
 

hammertimethere

Trevor Allan (34)
Poor James. But that said Simmons and Sharpe will have to be the locks for the Rugby championship now, and Pyle will need to be inserted if Sharpe is hell bent on retiring after super rugby. If not pyle then douglas (though I'm just not intimidated by him like I am by Horwill, Whitelock, Etzebeth, Bekker and of course thorn, same could be said for simmons.) or Timani. If Horwill makes it back he could partner pyle? actually that would suit me perfectly but thats a massive if. 2nd row stocks not really that flash currently are they
 

Richo

John Thornett (49)
Agree with that. Vickerman is knocking on the door of the knackers yard, he hasn't turned a wheel for the whole S15 season due to injury and even if he magically came right wouldn't be match fit.

Yep, at this point we have to consider Vicks to be done. No word yet out of Tahland, but they might have forgotten to announce the fact.
 

FANATIC

Fred Wood (13)
gee wizz
sounds like the best and often the only course of action is rest.'
This might see Sharpe hang about a bit longer

No Horwill or Sharpe... our line outs might lack some much needed direction.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top