Search results

Yes ap1, I too have commented on exactly this type of format but it won't happen unfortunately. There is no point in having a CAS specific divisional comp, there would be only 3 schools in div 1. It needs to involve multiple associations to have the sufficient number of schools to make a...

In all due respect AA, View isn't Joeys and I still don't see the logic. Why would a school stuff up all the lower grades when at best I think if teams were matched evenly View might win 50% of all games. I actually think that would also be a struggle against the Waves age groups. I think I...

Snort, Yes I have heard all that before and I did say that it would be fine where a school has more teams in an age group, then the fs can play some other school. However if any school has 5/6 teams in an age group I believe it is essential that these teams get matched up. Furthermore, without...

Having just seen the View v Waves Rugby fixtures for this Sat, they are quite upsetting. Other than each individual A age group View will be pitching lower teams against all the Waves Opens and age groups, eg the Waves 2s v View 3rds, Waves 3rds v View 5ths, and in the age groups it's Waves bs...

Ah yes, the Joker lurks in the background.:p

Touche Snort. It's a hung jury!

You are indeed a lawyer! If you approach the bench the distinction to be made here is that this is just footy talk, and in most cases here, dominant means territorial and ball retention dominance. Yes probably no/minimal points were scored but put simply, 1 side looked better than the other for...

Waves 13as won 73-7 Waves 14as won 29-12 Waves 15as won 21-10 Waves 16as won 26-0.

Agree RoD, Whilst I will be careful not to down play any school, in this case Waves v View both have solid depth typically, so why all the Waves Opens teams will have to play a lower View team appears a complete mismatch, and a waste of time. Time will tell but if this is what happens and if...

Hi Joker, My tips. 1. Knox by 17 2. Newington by 12 3. Joeys by 25 4. Waves by 21 5. Scots by 3

Hi DaS, To be honest, as a CAS follower, I am not thrilled to see any 2nds team playing another schools 1st team. In this case, when the Waves play View this Sat, the Waves 2nds look like they will be playing Views 3rds, and so down the grades it goes, mismatches. Not a particularly good early...

Hi Snort! I watched the New v Waves game last sat, a few observations. 1. Newington well deserved to win, they are a polished side and very fit. Whilst early days, I think they will definitely be a threat in the GPS comp. 2. Waves did have 2 key forwards and 2 key backs out, the backline had...

Very good attempt but not quite right, there would be several changes eg 14 in the 1sts is ineligible as he is now too old, and several other spots are probably not right, but it's just hypothetical.

Hello J, Look forward to another cracking year! Here are my unbiased tips :p 1. Barker by 7 2.Joeys by 15 3.Oakhill by 10 4.Kings by 10 5. Scots by 21 6.Waves by 14

Yep the New 16as was a very good side last year, beat Waves by a try on a rain sodden day at New and it could easily have gone the other way, the only game waves lost last year. Waves also beat Kings comfortably at Death Valley. However the waves have quite a number back from the 1s and 2s last...

Then it should be any interesting game at Death Valley, many are tipping New to win comfortably by 12-18+, will be very surprised if that happens but at this stage not too much is known of any team. Hope the rain stays away until after the game.

Wow, Newington must be very good this year, and good on them, why so?

Wow, Newington must be very strong this year, good on them, why so?

Spot on Snort, The reality is there are many footy boys who need an array of footy opportunities as they aren't necessarily academic or trade focused, so the fact that they have 2 code options is a benefit to them. You could also probably count AFL in this mix as there are transferable skills...