Search results

He WAS the best 12 we had, two seasons ago, If he can find that form again he will be, but he hasn't for a while, and has to prove himself. I'm sure RG has a logical explanation as to why Tapuai is used as a 13.

Really don't get this Tapuai love. He'd be behind even Fainga'a at this stage if it was up to me. I have not seen a single thing from him this season that warrants all this support. Aussie Mike has been very good as well

Nigel Genia would be playing 2nd Grade if he didn't have that last name.

The Sharks deserved the win, but were not that great. We deserved a bonus point, but were not that great at all. Both teams very inconsistent and all over the shop.

Aside from his bombed try, Harris ran some good lines. I haven't seen anything from Tapuai to warrant starting selection.

I think this is the only thing that lets him keep his spot. So many errors and poor decisions. Yes he is very dangerous in attack but he can't rely on that. I don't understand why his kicking as been so poor, every game I've seen him play before this season, his kicking as been near perfect...

Ball handling and execution for fucksake!! Good: Gill, Quirk, Genia Hit/miss: Mike Harris, Shatz Bad: Toua, Fainga'a, Holmes The only reason we even got within a sniff is because the Sharks let us.

All of you are talking about Saia of 2012/2013 He has been complete shit in the first three games. Hanson should be starting. I get the theory behind Saia starting (ie low tackles etc), but he has not been doing that consistently lately.

This is spot on. So much negativity going on, you could be forgiven for thinking we lost by 50pts on the weekend, not get a bonus point win.

I found myself yelling "GO DOS!" every time Toua got the ball. It has become a serious issue haha. Or something that has become common amongst my mates, the "NOT FRISBY" every time he comes on.

I said this in the Reds Thread, but I reckon McDuling at 6/8 could really benefit us against the Sharks pack, which lets be honest, if fucking terrifying. Losing bonus point will make me content.

I agree with TD, the strength of their Reserve Grade team really makes me think they will be strong this year. Depth is key in the Premier Comp.

I agree with Penguin. I think Quirk has looked much better than Shatz so far.

Well he scored four tries, so I imagine he wasn't completely shit haha

For some who agrees with it there was a lot of disagreements there :P

The Good: Rob Simmons, Rod Davies, Chris Feaiua-Sautia, James Hanson The Hit and Miss: Quade Cooper, Aiden Toua The Bad: Will Genia (wallaby 9 is anyone's for the taking ATM) Needs Improvement: Dom Shipperely, Jake Shatz Leave Them Off the Field: Saia Fainga'a, Nick Frisby Should Start Next...

That's it, his flowing locks and beard add on 5kgs

Bloke just keeps going!

I think McDuling should begin as a Lock/6 cover on the bench ahead of O'Donoghue as his first step into the team. I don't mind Ed O, but I think Dave would offer a little bit more.

BLASPHEMY!!