NSW AAGPS 2025 (banter and commentary)

[fortheloveofthegame]

yes they did win some games but the players in this version of the SA team were playing pro rugby in the URC against men at the time. Pathways, Pathways, we stick ours in cotton wool and call them PONIs, they send theirs out to prove themselves against men. These are the results.

 

[Rugbynbeers]

odd game, for the first part we actually looked solid but by the end of the second half the flood gates opened.

to make matters worse I think Fakafunu will be out for the tournament due to injury.

 

[FNC Rugby]

seriously, poor excuse. the GPS could have picked a team to win but picking on rep rather than form is a sad Australian rugby tradition.

Thats rugby as whole, lets pick players on a reputation they developed as a 13/14 year old and guide them through a pathway despite other great kids being better than them. Take a look at the 20's this morning.

 

[FNC Rugby]

Oh come on, guys, no need for all this gloom. CAS wins every so often, and this was one of those years. Plus, GPS still got 9 players in NSW 1sts to 6 from CAS - imagine how many would have been there if GPS won!

so by form more CAS players should have been selected, + ISA were superior to the GPS team as well.

 

[fortheloveofthegame]

Fakaunu will be missed. many oddities about the game. also interesting that the SA coach Kevin Foote was head coach at the Rebels. Australian development dollars at work yet again.

 

[twister29]

I say the selectors step aside next year, let the forum do the picking and choosing.

 

[The Cleaner]

GPS 3s looked the goods! Undefeated.

The only GPS team that didn't lose. And glad to see Tremlett and Viliamu being rewarded for their effort. I would think, Sawyer would have been selected also if he wasn't injured. Well done GPS 3 for holding the fort.

 

[The Cleaner]

I am looking forward to the battle in Gold Coast. There are 2 players that I want to see face off, QLD Taione Taka and NSW Creighton Meafou in the midfield. I'm hoping Taka will be playing but I wouldn't be surprised if he is straight to the PONI because he was ridiculously good in 2024 U16 Super rugby, 2024 Australian U16 and also 2025 REDs U18 this year.

 

[The 6 Seat]

I'm sure the combined power of @Joker and @The Chairman would create a world-beating side.

 

[twister29]

@The Cleaner has been on fire recently as well. I would also put @Jim Belshaw in for a country perspective.

 

[The Cleaner]

Oh no mate, I'll stay in my lane. I'll stick to the mower and the rake

 

[Jim Belshaw]

I fear that I would be of little use. While I'm in growing rebellion about metro dominance I struggle to understand pathways let alone access info on individual players. And then there are the girls! And the relationship with club rugby. To try to illustrate the complexity tas struggles to get games. Over the last three months, tas played games in Northwest rugby, new england rugby and ncis plus school visits and carnivals. In the Sydney Junior opens tas had 2 gps. Thirds, 1 country under 18 1 aices. In the later under 16s there was 1 gps, 3 aices. Even with all the school's work the thirds barely got a game. You can see why I find it all complicated!

 

[Joker]

Im sure the combined power of @Joker and @The Chairman would create a world-beating side.

 

[The Cleaner]

Has anyone seen any team list from the other states? Keen to see who is representing the other states. Should this be discussed here or need to be in another thread?

 

[Backintheolddays]

Yes the girls programs are screwed. None of the Sydney schools will travel to Orange so for reciprocal games Kinross is now looking to Canberra. Pretty poor form.

 

[Maul of Duty]

Will the NSW Schools 1 and 2 games be streamed again this year? Rugby TV maybe?

 

[Joker]

Lucky we don't have rugby this weekend.
Here is a photo of the new Scots aquatic centre

Here

 

[twister29]

Yes the girls programs are screwed. None of the Sydney schools will travel to Orange so for reciprocal games Kinross is now looking to Canberra. Pretty poor form.

Touch is pretty strong though. Seasons of netball and other popular sports that a lot of girls have grown up with collide with rugby seasons as well.

To keep it relevant to the GPS as well as addressing a question of mine, how do we think the girls are going to affect the depth of Newington’s rugby teams? Even 1s, 2s, 3s? Already with a limited number of open teams, less numbers may cause disruption in lower comps, like @Joker ’s beloved socials competition.

 

[The Ghost of Raelene]

Is it really going to do all that much? Are the student numbers increasing due to girls enrolling or are they staying the same which would mean less boys. If it's the later then it will have an effect across all sports but if it's increasing I expect no change and potentially extra resources since a lot of girls play touch and the growth of the NRL and Super Rugby W has more teams than ever in Rugby.

Barker is the case study. I'm fairly sure Barker Rugby Club in Subbies has a Womens team these days as well.

 

[DaSchmooze]

It will depend on whether local council will permit extra students on site. You only need ask Scots how difficult a proposition it is to get extra numbers through the gate.

If their numbers are fixed, then that means less boys and by default less competitiveness across all sports. If they are permitted extra numbers, then it comes down to an issue of resourcing all the additional sports programs that the girls parents will demand.